Why Tadhg Furlong wasn't banned over alleged testicle grab: URC finally issues 22-page decision
Still images consistent with video footage were pivotal in an independent United Rugby Championship (URC) disciplinary hearing committee’s decision not to uphold the testicle-grabbing complaint made against Tadhg Furlong, the Leinster and Ireland prop. The tighthead was cited last month following an allegation that he had grabbed Gavin Coombes’ testicles during a breakdown clear-out during Leinster’s October 24 win over Munster at the Aviva Stadium. The citing was not upheld , clearing Furlong to play for Ireland in this month’s Nations Championship , but only now, in the week of the November 21 Ireland versus Springboks match, the 22-page full written verdict from the October 28 hearing has been published. South African fans were anguished by the outcome that left Furlong cleared to play, accusing the URC of double standards as Jan-Hendrick Wessels copped an eight-week ban (initially nine weeks but reduced on appeal) after he was found guilty of allegedly grabbing, twisting, or squeezing the genitals of Connacht flanker Josh Murphy during a league game with the Bulls in Galway. “Better headspace...” Furlong, who denied having a post-game verbal exchange with Munster’s Coombes, based his testimony on footage labelled ‘5NL Corner’ and this resulted in the disciplinary committee consisting of Wales’ Simon Thomas (chair), Scotland’s Pamela Woodman and South Africa’s Attie Heyns deciding that the citing could not be upheld. In the written verdict, it was explained that Coombes, in conversation post-game with citing officer Peter Ferguson, said: “I just went into a defensive breakdown and I felt someone’s hand come up between my legs and grab. I notified our captain, Tadhg (Beirne), at the next stoppage. “I felt a hand come between my legs, and I think I reacted by pushing someone. I’m not sure (how long the incident lasted). It’s hard to know how much time in a game like that.” In the follow-up written statement presented at the hearing, Coombes elaborated: “I felt someone’s hand come up between my legs and then reach up and grab my testicles, then I felt a firm squeeze of my testicles from the player’s hand which lasted two or three seconds before I could react and push his hand away. “I then turned to see who it was and why he was doing such a thing. I said, ‘What the f*ck?’ I then let my captain know what had happened at the next stop of play, and he referred it to the referee. I also said to the Leinster player after the match, ‘You know what you did’. He replied, ‘Don’t point your finger at me’ and he offered no apology.” Under cross-examination from Derek Hegarty, the Leinster legal representative, Coombes described how he felt a lot of pressure upon him, not from any person, but from a recognition of the consequences of making the allegation because of Furlong’s high status in the public eye and in Ireland. “He described how he was having something of a ‘panic attack’, although qualified this to say he did not mean a full panic attack in the literal/medical sense. He said that he was worried about the consequences of being the victim in this situation.” Ex-Irish referee boss: The Tadhg Furlong defence that makes it ‘hard to convict’ him and why it was ‘different’ from Springbok’s nasty incident It was put to Coombes that he had not provided more detail to the citing commissioner and asked what had caused him to provide more detail in his later description; he said that “when he made his written statement, he did not feel under as much pressure and was in a ‘better headspace’ to explain matters without emotion clouding what he wanted to say. “When asked more about this ‘pressure’, he said that he knew social media would play a huge part and that being vilified was a real fear. However, he said he knew what had happened to him. He said he had had time to gather his emotions and had a clear head in which to give the details.” In his evidence, Furlong explained “that the ruck is a heavily refereed area and has changed a lot over the last three years, and that both for Leinster and for Ireland he is coached to use three points of contact. “These are a cleaning out movement with his shoulder or chest, his hand on the same side and then with the other hand reaching around ‘hooking a leg’ and lifting up and around to take their player off their feet and to finish on top.” Furlong was asked whether he had committed the act of foul play, in order to distract Coombes from attempting to compete for the ball. In response, he said that he hadn’t so and that his actions were very similar to the other legitimate instances of hooking of a leg and that “it would be nearly impossible to target someone at that speed and with that adjustment”. Furlong repeated that he had not grabbed Coombes’ testicles and also denied that after the match Coombes had said to him, “You know what you did” or that he had replied, “Don’t point your finger at me”. Rassie Erasmus faces possible World Rugby sanction after questioning ‘match-fixing’ Asked what his left hand had done whilst it was between Coombes’ legs, Furlong illustrated to the committee “how he had tension in his claw-like hand and forearm, but it was not in a grip. It was cupping the leg to make that ‘lift up motion’ to give the required leverage.” Furlong was then asked, when putting his hand between the legs of another player and exerting some pressure in a dynamic situation, whether there was “a risk he may squeeze, grasp or pull the genitals even if he did not intend to do it”, he said he did not accept there was a risk. In response to further committee questions, Furlong repeated he was 100 per cent certain his hand “did not make contact with Coombes’ testicles, unless his hand brushed them on the way in, but accepted some contact could have been made with another part of him”. Finally asked which part of Coombes’ leg his hand had made contact with, Furlong said it would have been “high up on the thigh”. The committee asked whether the frame-by-frame footage of 5 NL Corner could be shown in close up but with this not possible, it was decided that Furlong submit close up stills for the committee to consider when deliberating. The committee then went on to make 11 findings of fact in their verdict. They began by concluding Coombes “had given an honest account of his recollection of the incident and had not sought to embellish the facts of the case”. They also noted that Coombes was reticent with the citing commissioner post-game about “certain details surrounding it, including the identity of the player whom he accused, the duration of the incident, or how the pressure to his testicles had made him feel”. Ireland coach: Rassie Erasmus’ late changes are ‘not in the spirit of the game’ With regard to the alleged post-game verbal exchange between the players, the committee “did not consider it necessary to resolve that dispute and attached little weight to it, as neither version sheds light on what happened at the ruck”. Reflecting on the video evidence presented along with still images, it stated: “On first viewing, the video footage appeared to be consistent with the allegation... on closer examination of the slow-motion footage and the frame-by-frame stills, however, that impression was displaced. “The committee found that the firm squeeze of two to three seconds described by Mr Coombes could not have occurred. The committee concluded that the player’s description of his left hand being shown away from the genital area and more towards the lower part of Mr Coombes’ shorts was more consistent with the footage than the allegation that his hand was in a position to grab and squeeze Mr Coombes’ testicles. Want more from Planet Rugby? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for world-class coverage you can trust. “In the committee’s view, the most likely cause of what Mr Coombes felt: a static, all-round pressure arising from his own legs closing around the player’s arm, rather than from any grip by the player’s hand. When Mr Coombes then reached down and found the player’s hand in the general area of his upper thigh and/or genitals, he honestly, but mistakenly, believed that it was the hand which had grabbed and squeezed him.” Having found as a fact that Furlong had not grabbed, squeezed or twisted Coombes’ testicles, the question of recklessness therefore did not arise and the citing complaint wasn’t upheld. READ MORE: Who’s hot and who’s not: ‘Cult status’ Wales, ‘overindulgent’ Springboks, All Blacks ‘stigma’ and ‘dinosaur’ Eddie Jones