Who’s winning the Heisman Trophy? Jeremiah Smith, Darian Mensah lead 10 contenders after Week 11

After losing ground for three weeks, Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith extended his lead in the Heisman Trophy race with a strong showing in Week 11 of the college football season. Smith reversed a trend that took effect after Buckeyes quarterback Julian Sayin was injured Oct. 17 against Indiana. Since then, Smith has worked to form chemistry with QB Luke Fahey. Saturday in a 28-19 win against Northwestern, the duo had its best game. It showed in The Athletic ’s latest Heisman Trophy poll of writers and editors. A question remains for Smith: Can his candidacy withstand an absence on conference-championship weekend, the final opportunity for contenders to make a statement to voters? Conference titles will be determined on Dec. 4 and 5. Heisman votes are due on Dec. 7. Ohio State, at 7-3 overall and 5-2 in the Big Ten, must navigate a winding path — with key games out of the Buckeyes’ control — to return to the championship game for the second consecutive season after a four-year absence. Most important, Ohio State must win Saturday at Nebraska and Nov. 28 against Michigan. On Monday, Nebraska coach Matt Rhule described Smith as “undoubtedly the best player in college football.” Rhule said Smith reminds him of former Alabama great Julio Jones. Regardless, if Smith is sitting at home on the first weekend of December while quarterbacks Darian Mensah of Miami, Devon Dampier of Utah and Gio Lopez of Wake Forest slug it out with the full attention of Heisman voters, Smith stands to lose some support. How much? It likely depends on Smith’s body of work after Ohio State matches up against the Huskers and archrival Wolverines. Smith shattered the Big Ten career receiving-yardage record last week in addition to FBS records for the most receiving touchdowns and the most receiving yardage in a player’s first three years. In 10 games, he sits ninth on the Big Ten single-season leaderboard with 1,317 yards. Smith needs 290 yards to break the record set in 2021 by Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Here’s a look at the candidates with three weeks left to sort out the race: 1. Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State (last week: 1) Last week: 11 catches, 117 yards, 1 touchdown vs. Northwestern The Heisman favorite enjoyed his best day since he posted back-to-back, 200-yard receiving efforts at the start of Big Ten play against Illinois and Iowa. Smith’s 10-yard scoring catch from Fahey in the fourth quarter put the Buckeyes up two scores for good. 2. Darian Mensah, Miami (last week: 3) Last week: 30-for-41 passing, 382 yards, 1 touchdown vs. Duke His consistency is something to behold. The performance against Duke, turnover-free for the eighth time in 10 games, marked Mensah’s seventh outing this year with a completion rate above 70 percent. He answered every Duke score on Saturday with a score for the Hurricanes until the final minute. 3. Devon Dampier, Utah (last week: 4) Last week: 13-for-25 passing, 204 yards, 2 touchdowns, 1 interception vs. Arizona The senior from Phoenix has something that no other candidate can claim: Control of an offense for a team that has yet to lose. Dampier rushed for 100 yards and two touchdowns in addition to his passing numbers as the Utes came from behind in the final three minutes to win 40-39. Dampier’s 70-yard strike to Creed Whittemore erased Utah’s fourth deficit of the day. 4. Gio Lopez, Wake Forest (last week: T7) Last week: 14-for-25 passing, 201 yards, 1 touchdown vs. SMU More than the numbers, which are gaudy, Lopez is leading a locomotive. Wake Forest went up 42-0 at halftime en route to a 49-7 win at SMU. The Demon Deacons have throttled every ACC opponent since the start of October. Lopez is the engineer. He also ran for two scores against the Mustangs. 5. CJ Carr, Notre Dame (last week: 2) Last week: 20-for-28 passing, 217 yards, 2 touchdowns, 1 interception vs. Boston College Rather workmanlike for the second-year starter in a 41-7 win against BC. Carr didn’t complete a pass longer than 26 yards, and the interception was his first since Sept. 19. Only reeling SMU and a trip to Syracuse stand between the Irish and a CFP berth. 6. Nate Sheppard, Duke (last week: T7) Last week: 16 rushes, 131 yards, 2 touchdowns vs. Miami His support remained steady despite the Blue Devils’ third defeat. Sheppard’s 19 rushing touchdowns and his 1,320 yards rank second nationally. Against Miami, he was arguably the most dynamic player on the field. In addition to the rushing production, Sheppard caught 12 passes for 93 yards and he completed two passes. T7. Aiden Flora, Iowa State (last week: unranked) Last week: 28 rushes, 216 yards, 3 touchdowns vs. Cincinnati Six touchdowns and 619 yards in the past three games? That’ll play for a sophomore who played sparingly a year ago. His 1,335 rushing yards lead the FBS. The Cyclones are a pleasant surprise with five wins. And Flora caught four passes in the latest win, 41-13 against Cincinnati. His 7.2-yard rushing average is the fourth-highest nationally among backs with 100 carries. T7. Malachi Toney, Miami (last week: 6) Last week: Did not play. Despite missing the past two games, he’s still among seven 1,000-yard receivers in the FBS. His 13 touchdowns rank third nationally. And now this from coach Mario Cristobal: Toney is recovering from ankle surgery ahead of schedule. A return for the Dec. 5 ACC championship game is not out of the question. T9. Noah Fifita, Arizona (last week: unranked) Last week: 27-for-43 passing, 356 yards, 3 touchdowns, 1 interception vs. Utah Arizona came up short, but Fifita torched Utah’s secondary for his fifth consecutive 300-yard passing effort. His 3,150 yards through the air rank third nationally — and highest among QBs to register in the polling. T9. Carlos Hernandez, Wake Forest (last week: unranked) Last week: 6 receptions, 94 yards, 1 touchdown vs. SMU The big day against SMU put Hernandez over 1,000 yards for the season. He is Lopez's top receiving target and a dynamic weapon at 6 feet and 190 pounds out of Alhambra, Calif. The second-year player for the Demon Deacons started his career at Washington State. Opportunities against Georgia Tech, Duke and perhaps Miami await.