Where does UTEP belong among the 10 toughest coaching jobs in college football right now? - The New York Times

What is the toughest job in major college football? The best job among the college game’s elite programs is debated frequently — Texas, Ohio State, Georgia, etc. — but there are far more difficult jobs than good jobs, and multiple of the former have opened in this coaching carousel. UTEP’s firing of Scotty Walden on Monday brings the question back to mind. Of the six current head coach openings in the Football Bowl Subdivision , I’ve graded half a D+ or worse, including UTEP. Last year, The Athletic surveyed coaches and staffers to determine the toughest Power 4 and Group of 6 jobs . As someone who has covered coaching changes for more than a decade, here is my educated ranking of the toughest jobs. 1. Kent State Every year, Kent State signs up to get pounded by two or three high-level Power 4 programs, just for a paycheck. It was Ohio State and South Carolina this year, and it was Oklahoma, Texas Tech and Florida State the year prior. (A trip to Notre Dame is scheduled for next year’s season opener.) As a result, every season starts in a hole, and the coach is operating under a low ceiling because of it. MAC play hasn’t been much better, with just six winning records in conference play since 1988. There have been brief moments of success, including MAC championship game appearances in 2021 and 2012. Former head coach Sean Lewis turned success into the Colorado offensive coordinator job. But the Golden Flashes are also near the bottom of the MAC and FBS in spending on their football program, according to the Knight-Newhouse college athletics database . Hence the paycheck games. Coaches also ranked it the toughest job last year. 2. Akron The stadium is really nice. That’s about it. Akron has just one winning season in the last 20 years (2015), plus a MAC championship game appearance in 2017 en route to a 7-7 finish. The last season with more than eight wins was 50 years ago, in 1976. The Zips even dealt with a bowl ban in 2025 over academics. This job is not as rough as Kent State’s because its nonconference scheduling strategy provides a little more upside (Akron beat Northwestern in 2018). The facilities are OK, relatively speaking, and there are football players in Ohio, but the Zips are at the bottom of the MAC in spending, working with half (at best) of what the league’s top teams spend. 3. Louisiana-Monroe The Warhawks moved up to the FBS in 1994 and have just one winning record to show for it, an 8-5 season in 2012. They won a Sun Belt championship in 2005, but their 5-2 conference record was part of a 5-6 overall record. They’re at the very bottom of the FBS financially: They didn’t pay out full cost-of-attendance to scholarships until 2021 and regularly have one of the subdivision’s lowest-paid coaches. Current coach Bryant Vincent even pulled double duty as athletic director for months last year. It’s been bad enough that public figures around the school every few years have to address the idea of dropping back down to the Football Championship Subdivision. But if rivals Louisiana and Louisiana Tech can have plenty of success, why can’t ULM? 4. New Mexico State The legend of Diego Pavia keeps this job from the bottom. Pavia and coach Jerry Kill went 17-11 together at New Mexico State from 2022 to ’23, including a win over Auburn. But the Aggies have only three bowl appearances since 1961 and have among the fewest resources in the country. A new football building opened last year, but there is no indoor practice field. Las Cruces is an isolated location for FBS football, an hour north of El Paso and far from recruiting hotbeds. The Aggies were kicked out of the Sun Belt with Idaho, went independent, then joined Conference USA during a more recent round of realignment. But when nearby rival UTEP got invited to the Mountain West (where fellow rival New Mexico sits), New Mexico State was left behind. 5. UTEP Walden’s firing on Monday made him the latest in a long line of coaches who couldn’t find success in El Paso. The program’s last bowl win was 60 years ago, in 1967. The Miners haven’t won more than eight games since 1988 and have had just two winning seasons in the last 20 years. The program is also extremely isolated, closer to the California border than it is to Dallas. There is no indoor practice field in a state where many high school programs have them. UTEP’s football spending is also near the bottom of the new Mountain West. 6. Sacramento State The Hornets’ move up to the FBS was strange, as was their conference landing spot in the MAC, and their long-term prospects remain extremely uncertain. 7. UMass There’s been no winning at all since the FBS move in 2012, but the Minutemen are now near the top of the MAC in football spending, at least. They need to win their final two games this season to make their first FBS bowl. 8. Temple The Owls have money relative to the rest of the Group of 6 but not relative to their foes in the high-spending American Conference. Multiple coaches won here a decade ago, but the lack of an on-campus stadium (Temple plays at Lincoln Financial Field, home of the Philadelphia Eagles) remains a sore spot. 9. Rice It’s in talent-rich Houston, but the academic standards and the strength of the American Conference make for a low ceiling. 10. Rutgers It feels hopeless competing against schools spending far more money. The Scarlet Knights haven’t beaten a ranked team since 2009. This season’s blowout loss to UMass was a new low. But before you leave too depressed, two of the toughest Power 4 jobs, according to coaches last year, were UCLA and Wake Forest. Now, both are in position for the College Football Playoff this year.