What’s the risk of Red Wings’ waiting too long on Simon Edvinsson, Dylan Larkin deals?
A quarter of the way through the season, the Detroit Red Wings have seen their ups and downs but are overall about where we thought they’d be — with one exception. They still have some major off-ice business to resolve. That was the focus from readers when we opened up the mailbag last week. Let’s dive right into it. Note: Some questions have been lightly edited for clarity. What are your thoughts on the potential Michael Misa for Simon Edvinsson trade that is currently popular internet fodder? — Bruce F. I definitely see the logic in it. For the Red Wings, the pain of trading Edvinsson would be losing a rare player type: a 6-foot-6 defenseman who skates like a gazelle, takes tough minutes and has the skill to put up 50 points, especially if he ever got power-play time. At age 23, that’s extremely valuable. Misa, though, would still be quite valuable as a speedy 6-1 center who has already reached the NHL at age 19, giving him more runway to keep blossoming. The Red Wings know how hard it is to find a young top-six center, and Misa would be just that while also fitting the age of their young core quite well. His 8 five-on-five points this season aren’t splashy, but it’s worth noting he would be fourth on the Red Wings. And again: He’s 19. The Red Wings have said all along they want to sign Edvinsson , and rightfully so. If they trade him, odds are they won’t find a defenseman quite like him for many years, but to the best of my knowledge, Edvinsson’s mind is made up, and if that’s the case, Misa is a worthy headliner who would legitimately help the Red Wings’ outlook. If I were the Red Wings, I’d ask for Misa and a high-level “B” prospect such as Haoxi Wang or Teddy Mutryn, but if it had to be a one-for-one, that’s not the end of the world. It’s the top asset that counts most. Top Plays from Red Wings @ Lightning Time frame aside, would it be prudent to move Edvinsson first and potentially obtain a Misa (SJ) or Caleb Desnoyers (Utah) plus assets? Then you would have more flexibility with a Dylan Larkin deal for a top-flight defenseman and assets? — John D. Yes, there’s merit to the Red Wings’ securing a center via Edvinsson first . Whether it’s Misa, Desnoyers or someone else — I am also intrigued by the Nashville Predators’ Wyatt Cullen and the St. Louis Blues’ Tynan Lawrence, among others — getting that young top-six center for Edvinsson opens up Detroit’s options with Larkin. The Red Wings should still be looking for quality over quantity, but even quantity can have some value as capital for future trades. If Detroit had multiple extra first-round picks in the coming years, for example, it could plan on targeting a young defenseman who becomes available in the near future, as the Carolina Hurricanes did in trading for K’Andre Miller in July 2025. That approach doesn’t help the Red Wings as much right now, but it could still prove fruitful in the coming years (especially with the number of players requesting trades as of late). As for getting a top-flight defenseman directly in a Larkin deal, it’s hard to say whether there is a realistic one out there, at least on Larkin’s list. One prominent name would be Carolina’s Alexander Nikishin, who also had a contract dispute with the Hurricanes this fall before signing a one-year deal in late October. He had 11 goals and 33 points as a rookie last season while playing just 18 minutes a night, and at 25, the 6-3 defenseman still fits the Red Wings’ age range. All of that seems appealing. But there are also real questions there. Does Detroit really want to face another difficult RFA negotiation less than a year from now? And beyond that, what does Nikishin look like outside of Carolina’s favorable environment? Would he be as effective in the top four in Detroit? Still, the answer to your main question holds: Getting a center for Edvinsson would at least help the Red Wings be more flexible on what a Larkin return needs to look like, albeit more in make-up than in overall value. How much of a concern is the strategy of putting pressure on Edvinsson by waiting him out until Dec. 1, assuming he is unwilling to re-sign, that other teams will lower their offers as Detroit loses leverage as they get closer to losing him for the entire season? — Jason A. It is a real concern, and one probably not being talked about enough. The framing of the situation tends to be pressure on Edvinsson to sign or sit out a year, and that would indeed be hard on him. He only has so many years in his prime, which he appears to be just entering. It’s a real pressure point. But a cliff exists for Detroit, too. If Edvinsson loses the ability to play in the NHL this year, there’s less urgency from other teams to trade for his rights this season, which could end up just pushing the issue into the summer. The Red Wings can technically take that route, with Edvinsson then able to play back home in Sweden, but that doesn’t make him more likely to ever sign with them and could introduce more issues if he were to get hurt. Beyond that, though the Edvinsson and Larkin situations are an unenviable combination for interim general manager Shawn Horcoff, they are at least an opportunity to show what he can do in the GM chair. Losing one of those opportunities until the summer doesn’t seem ideal as he seeks the permanent title. And though this question was about Edvinsson, there’s some risk in waiting too long with Larkin, albeit to a much lesser degree. On one hand, Larkin’s cap hit gets more manageable the longer the Red Wings wait (assuming the acquiring team is banking cap space right now), but there is also a risk other enticing trade candidates emerge as time goes on. Right now, Larkin is the biggest name on the market. Will that still be the case in February? Though the Tampa Bay Lightning have said they have no intention of moving Nikita Kucherov, his situation is an example of how quickly the landscape can change. Horcoff has handled himself well to this point. He hasn’t caved to pressure or noise, but if Edvinsson really won’t sign, making a trade before the deadline (and, to Jason’s point, before teams start to use that deadline against them) makes the most sense. Do you think maybe the Red Wings need to go ahead and put Marco Kasper between Raymond and MBN? Let him grow into it and leave him alone. That would solve their 1 and 2 center issue, making a trade for Larkin that much easier. Kasper was drafted to be a top-two center. — James H. Yes, I’d like to see Kasper between Raymond and Michael Brandsegg-Nygård. I don’t think it would solve the center issue in the big picture — Detroit will still need a long-term No. 1 — but giving him the chance in a second-line center role makes a lot of sense, not least because he’s playing great hockey since returning from injury. Kasper has just one goal in four games this season, but he’s been highly noticeable, competing hard and tilting the ice in Detroit’s favor. His 64.78 percent expected goals share while on the ice at five-on-five leads the team, per Natural Stat Trick, though his sample is small. Of course, Kasper is already playing next to Alex DeBrincat and Emmitt Finnie, so he’s getting a great look next to key players already, but ideally, you want him to be a center, and this is a good opportunity to play him there. The short-term tension is whether they want to disrupt things while Kasper is playing well on the wing. The fact Detroit is coming off a shutout win adds to that. We’ll see where it goes, but another look at center definitely makes sense. What is the chance of Daniil Tarasov taking over the No. 1 goaltending spot from John Gibson? — Anonymous U. Tarasov has been excellent for the Red Wings this season, with a .931 save percentage that ranks second in the NHL, and his 9.66 goals saved above expected (according to Evolving-Hockey) rank third. So yes, he’s earned more action, full stop. I’d be careful in flipping the pair’s usage outright, though, for two reasons: Tarasov’s career high is 33 games (last season), and the Red Wings still have plenty of reason to try to help Gibson find his game — including the impact on his potential trade value. I’d try something like a 50-50 split for now, testing Tarasov’s ability to handle the increased workload and giving Gibson more opportunities to find his game, but there’s zero doubt who Detroit’s best netminder has been so far this year, and that’s Tarasov.