What Gavin Coombes Actually Alleged Against Tadhg Furlong – URC Report Released

The URC have released a detailed report into their process, after they cleared Leinster's Tadhg Furlong of any wrongdoing following an allegation that he had grabbed the crotch of Munster player Gavin Coombes in last month's interprovincial derby. Furlong was accused of grabbing Coombes' testicles in a ruck during the first half of the interprovincial derby, an allegation which overshadowed the game at the Aviva Stadium. Recommended The veteran Ireland prop was cited for the incident under Law 9.27, which states, " A player must not do anything that is against the spirit of good sportsmanship including but not limited to grabbing, twisting or squeezing the genitals." Both Furlong and Coombes gave testimony to a panel comprised of Simon Thomas (Wales), Attie Heyns (South Africa), and Pamela Woodman Scotland), who "unanimously concluded that the citing complaint against the player should be dismissed, on the basis that he did not commit an act of foul play contrary to Law 9.27." Their verdict freed Furlong to play for Ireland in the November internationals . Munster Rugby released a furious response, saying: We believe it is important that independent disciplinary proceedings are allowed to conclude without unhelpful commentary from people with a clear influence over public perception. Respect for that process, and consideration for everyone directly involved should be paramount. Leinster coach Robin McBryde and Ireland coach Johnny Sexton had both made public remarks defending Furlong's character in the week following the incident. The URC have now issued a detailed report into the incident, revealing the exact nature of Coombes' accusation; the fear the Munster man felt for a backlash from supporters; a further confrontation between the players on the field; and their reasoning for clearing Furlong of wrongdoing. Full details of Gavin Coombes' Furlong accusation released In the URC's report released to the media this week, the exact details of Gavin Coombes' allegation against Tadhg Furlong were made public. Coombes stated the following about the ruck which took place after a tackle on Leinster's Joe McCarthy in the 37th minute of last month's interprovincial derby in the Aviva Stadium: "During this I felt someone's hand come up between my legs and then reach up and grab my testicles," Coombes' written statement said. Then I felt a firm squeeze of my testicles from the players hand which lasted 2 or 3 seconds before I could react and push his hand away. I then turned to see who it was and why he was doing such a thing - "I said what the f*ck?" I then let my captain know what had happened at the next stop of play and he referred it to the referee. Coombes also revealed he had confronted Furlong at full time. I also said to the Leinster player after the match, 'You know what you did,' he replies [sic] 'Don't point your finger at me,' and he offered no apology. Leinster man Furlong was offered the opportunity to give a defence, and explained what he believed had transpired. Furlong said that his technique in entering the ruck to "clean" Coombes was informed by new maul rules, which mean players defending a maul from the outside are not allowed to touch the ground with their hand. To counter this, he wrapped his left arm around the opponent and hooked underneath and between the legs. Furlong said it would be "nearly impossible to target" a player's crotch at that speed making such an adjustment. He attested he had not made contact, "Unless his hand brushed them on the way in, but accepted some contact could have been made with another part of him." URC's Tadhg Furlong verdict explained Ultimately, the panel exonerated Tadhg Furlong of any wrongdoing, but said that they found Gavin Coombes' account "honest...with no embellishment." They did, however, note that Coombes' written statement provided further information than his initial report to the citing commissioner; they noted he had been somewhat 'reticent' about some details during his initial report, per the Irish Examiner . The panel also said that Tadhg Furlong was "entitled to call into question the accuracy of Mr Coombes' evidence, given the absence of a detailed account when he had an earlier opportunity to provide one." Here is the full reasoning for the panel's decision: The Committee therefore concluded that, on the balance of probabilities, the most likely scenario was that, during the fast-moving and dynamic ruck, Mr Coombes felt pressure applied to his testicles and believed at the time that the Player had grabbed them. The Committee accepted the Player’s account, which can also be seen on the video footage, that as Mr Coombes fell onto his side his legs closed tightly around the Player’s hand and forearm. In the Committee’s view, that is the most likely cause of what Mr Coombes felt: a static, all-round pressure arising from his own legs closing around the Player’s arm, rather than from any grip by the Player’s hand. When Mr Coombes then reached down and found the Player’s hand in the general area of his upper thigh and/or genitals, he honestly, but mistakenly, believed that it was the hand which had grabbed and squeezed him. Coombes feared backlash for accusation There is further information in the report about the mental toll the incident took on both players. Gavin Coombes feared that he would be vilified for his accusation by the general public and on social media. The report notes that Coombes "described how he f elt a lot of pressure upon him, not from any person, but from a recognition of the consequences of making the allegation, because of the player's high status in the public eye and in Ireland. " He described how he was having something of a "panic attack", although qualified this to say he did not mean a full panic attack in the literal/medical sense. He said that he was worried about the consequences of being the victim in this situation." Tadhg Furlong, too, was affected by the allegation, with Guy Easterby of Leinster attesting to the "upset and distress which the player had demonstrated following the allegation."