Unemployment falls but vacancies remain at 12-year low

Unemployment has dropped to its lowest rate in 17 months, but the headline figure masks a stalled jobs market, with vacancies at their lowest level since 2014, outside the pandemic, and real pay growth all but wiped out by rising inflation. The UK unemployment rate fell to 4.6% in the latest quarter, according to labour market figures published today by the Office for National Statistics (ONS), but employers’ appetite to hire remains weak. Early estimates suggest there were 690,000 vacancies in August to October 2026, down 22,000 (3%) on May to July. Vacancies fell in 11 of the 18 industry sectors, with the largest decreases in administrative and support service activities, construction, and transport and storage, each down 5,000. Small businesses saw the sharpest drop. Vacancies at firms with one to nine employees fell by 22,000, the largest decrease of any employer size band. There were 2.4 unemployed people per vacancy in July to September, down from 2.5 in April to June. Annual growth in employees’ regular earnings was 3.5%, while total earnings growth (including bonuses) was 3.6%. Adjusted for inflation using the consumer prices index including owner-occupiers’ housing costs (CPIH), however, real pay grew by just 0.2% for regular pay and 0.3% for total pay. The ONS published the figures on the same day as the final report of Alan Milburn’s review of youth employment, which is expected later. ‘Flicker of relief’ James Cockett, senior labour market economist at the CIPD, said the figures offered “a flicker of relief, but the labour market is still largely stalled”. “A lack of appetite among employers to hire is concerning. Fewer vacancies in a bigger labour market means finding a job will be harder than ever, particularly for young people,” he said. “Employers tell us that cost and risk, not a lack of need, are what’s holding them back. That’s why the Milburn review matters. Its recommendations, including doubling the National Insurance threshold for 21–24-year-olds, recognise that the cost of taking on new staff has become a real barrier.” However, Cockett warned that “a stalled jobs market won’t be unstuck by tax tweaks alone”, calling for closer working between government and business, and “sensible compromise on zero-hours reform, so the flexible roles many young people rely on as a first step into work aren’t legislated away”. Naomi Clayton, chief executive of the Institute for Employment Studies, cautioned that the fall in unemployment partly reflects changes to the ONS’s survey sample “rather than clear evidence of a stronger labour market”. “Hiring remains weak and vacancies have fallen to the lowest level in 12 years, outside the pandemic,” she said. Lee Chant, managing director at ManpowerGroup UK & Ireland, said the labour market “continues to appear resilient on the surface”, but sentiment was weaker than the headline data suggested. “Last month’s Budget presented an opportunity to restore business confidence, but many employers feel it fell short of addressing their most pressing concerns,” he said. “Hiring has not stopped, but businesses are becoming increasingly selective about where and when they invest in talent.” Young people ‘bearing the brunt’ Youth unemployment remains a central concern. According to Clayton, unemployment among 16- to 24-year-olds stands at 15.1%, more than three times the overall rate. Ben Harrison, director of the Work Foundation at Lancaster University, said the UK’s “jobs drought” was persisting. Youth unemployment had dipped slightly on the year but remained historically high at 688,000. He pointed to the strain on traditional youth employers, with retail employment at its lowest level since 1994 after 60,000 jobs were shed in the past year. Work Foundation research shows starter job vacancies have fallen by 49% over the past decade, with particularly acute shortages in the North and Midlands. “Alan Milburn is right to call for a ‘complete system reset’ to tackle the youth employment crisis, but its success must be measured by how many young people move into sustained employment, not by reductions in the benefits bill,” Harrison said. “The reality is that Neet young people can’t access jobs that simply don’t exist.” The Resolution Foundation offered a more positive reading of the latest ONS statistics for young workers. Although payrolled employment has fallen by 21,000 over the past three months, and is down 215,000 since October 2024, the number of 18 to 24-year-olds in payrolled jobs rose by 34,000 over the quarter and by 58,000 over the year. Payrolled employment among those aged 25 and over fell by 39,000 and 119,000 over the same periods. Nye Cominetti, principal economist at the think tank, said: “Young people are showing a surprising resilience. The number of 18 to 24-year-olds in payrolled jobs is rising, despite weak hiring, even as employment falls for older workers. The latest data is an encouraging basis on which to start a new strategy to bring down the Neet rate.” Real pay squeeze returns With inflation picking up, commentators warned that workers face a renewed squeeze on living standards. The Resolution Foundation said that, with inflation forecast to rise to almost 5% by next spring, real wage growth is expected to turn negative by the winter. Cockett said: “Workers are seeing pay rises eaten away, with employers already stretched by higher employment costs having little room to respond. That points to a renewed squeeze on household budgets heading into the new year.” Keith Rosser, chair of the Better Hiring Institute, said rising employment costs were pushing businesses to consider alternatives to recruitment, including fractional work, automation, AI and offshoring. He warned of an “AI arms race in recruitment, with candidates using technology to apply for more jobs and employers using it to filter more applications, without necessarily improving outcomes for either side”. “The danger is that we’re making a broken recruitment system faster, rather than better at connecting the right people with the right jobs,” he said. Sign up to our weekly round-up of HR news and guidance Receive the Personnel Today Direct e-newsletter every Wednesday Rob Moss Rob Moss is a business journalist with more than 25 years' experience. He has been editor of Personnel Today since 2010. He joined the publication in 2006 as online editor of the award-winning website. Rob specialises in labour market economics, gender diversity and family-friendly working. He has hosted hundreds of webinars and podcasts. Before writing about HR and employment he ran news and feature desks on publications serving the global optical and eyewear market, the UK electrical industry, and energy markets in Asia and the Middle East.