U.S. Court Dismisses $25 Million Ethereum MEV Fraud Case Against the Perreira-Bueno Brothers

In April 2023, unknown traders executed a sophisticated attack on bots engaged in extracting maximum extractable value (MEV) on the Ethereum blockchain. Exploiting features of the MEV-Boost software, the attackers created fraudulent transactions that allowed them to manipulate trading bots of other market participants and intercept trades. The traders replaced legitimate bot transactions with malicious ones, enabling them to siphon over $25 million within seconds, according to prosecutors. MEV is the profit that can be extracted by manipulating the order of transactions in a block. The strategy behind such " sandwich attacks ": traders create fake transactions on illiquid assets to lure trading bots. Then, these transactions are canceled or altered before they are included on the blockchain, for example, due to increased fees. As a result, the bots execute unfavorable trades, while the traders profit from this. According to the prosecution, the Pereira-Bueno brothers planned these manipulations for several months. The prosecutors assert that the brothers acquired the skills they used in their trading strategy at MIT. In 2023, Anton Pereira earned a bachelor’s degree in computer science and engineering. James Pereira received a bachelor’s degree in mathematics and aeronautics in 2019, followed by a master’s degree in aeronautics in 2021. In spring 2024, the Pereira-Bueno brothers were arrested on charges of exploiting vulnerabilities in Ethereum validator software. The brothers' lawyers insist that the trading strategy they used was legal. U.S. Federal Judge Jessica Clarke agreed with the defense’s arguments, noting that such activities were not conducted on a regulated market where such actions would be prohibited. Clarke explained that the issue is not whether the brothers’ trading strategy was unethical, but whether it constitutes fraud using electronic communications. The court ruled that the defendants’ actions do not constitute a criminal offense, as the prosecution failed to prove any act of deception. In November 2025, the court was unable to reach a verdict in this case because the jury could not agree. Peter Van Valkenburgh, Executive Director of Coin Center, which advocates for cryptocurrency companies, called the Pereira-Bueno case a serious overreach by law enforcement. According to him, the brothers did not violate any rules established by the Ethereum protocol. «Among validators, there is no concept of 'honor.' The only requirement for a validator or MEV extractor is to maximize profit, including only valid transactions in blocks,» explained Valkenburg. Last year, analysts at Lookonchain found that the Ethereum sandwich-bot JaredFromSubway, which since 2023 had stolen millions of dollars from traders on decentralized exchanges, lost $7.7 million itself. Some of the stolen funds were laundered through the crypto mixer TornadoCash. Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information. Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure .