Tuesday’s analyst upgrades and downgrades
Inside the Market’s roundup of some of today’s key analyst actions Desjardins Securities analyst Jerome Dubreuil was “surprised” by Quebecor Inc. ’s ( QBR-B-T ) $31-billion proposal to acquire rival Telus Corp. ( T-T ), but he sees “a compelling long-term strategic rationale for the Québec-based cableco, with the transaction potentially transforming the industry’s small disruptor into a scaled national telecom player.” “While the large premium (44 per cent on Monday’s close) and valuation (8.0 times our FY27 adjusted EBITDA estimate) are attractive, T’s board has to weigh that against (1) significant regulatory risk, and (2) the prospect of selling to a highly valued QBR while its own shares were depressed,” he said. “We like the destination for QBR, but the road there looks challenging, with T likely demanding meaningful deal-certainty protections and a pro forma entity being more difficult to value. We note that T has not accepted the offer; QBR has simply made its proposal public.” Andrew Willis: Mélanie Joly is speaking a new language on potential Quebecor-Telus deal In a client note titled A swing for the fences , Mr. Dubreuil emphasized regulatory approval is “likely the biggest hurdle” to a deal moving forward. “From three to four, and (maybe) back to three. Ottawa and the CRTC have spent years fostering a fourth national wireless competitor, including by (1) putting in place the seven-year MVNO access, (2) establishing spectrum set-asides, (3) requiring mandatory roaming on the Big 3’s networks, and (4) forcing RCI to divest Freedom,” he explained. “We believe the government has achieved its affordability objectives, but the 2027 federal budget continues to emphasize greater competition, consumer choice and affordability. Allowing QBR to acquire T would seemingly run counter to that objective by reducing the national wireless market from four players back to three. “There is a trend toward three-player markets. Three-player wireless markets are common internationally and would seemingly be consistent with Canada’s relatively modest population and large country size. The UK recently consolidated from four operators to three, while France appears to be moving in a similar direction amid SFR’s challenges. The U.S. remains a unique case, but we think it is fair to say that the standalone fourth-player experiment with DISH has not been a success. We think the commoditization of networks and high product maturity explain this trend.” Also seeing emphasizing getting the approval of Telus board as another barrier, Mr. Dubreuil cut his target for Quebecor shares to $76 from $82 with a “buy” rating while raising his Telus target to $14.50 from $13 with a “hold” recommendation. The averages on the Street are $79.50 and $13.82, respectively. “We used a probability-weighted approach to support our revised target prices,” he explained. “Under a no-deal scenario, we believe QBR would revert to a 2.0 times EV/EBITDA premium to the Big 3 on FY27 estimates, below the 2.4 times premium implied by last Friday’s (November 13) close. We believe a tighter multiple gap is warranted since (1) QBR’s offer for T could reshape regulators’ perception of the company in future regulatory decisions, and (2) the bid has demonstrated QBR’s willingness to pursue acquisitions to increase scale, introducing M&A risk into the valuation. Under a deal scenario, to which we currently assign a 25-per-cent probability, we believe a combined QBR/T could ultimately trade at a 1.0 times EV/EBITDA premium to the average multiple of BCE and RCI, supported by industry-low capital intensity and a leading EBITDA growth profile. “Applying these probability-weighted outcomes, we lowered our target price to $76 (from $82) and reiterate our Buy rating on QBR, although it remains our lowestranked Buy, behind BCE and RCI. We also highlight two factors that could limit QBR’s near-term upside: (1) the added complexity of valuing a combined QBR/T could lead investors to ascribe a tighter premium vs BCE and RCI, and (2) QBR may need to strengthen the terms of its offer to limit T’s downside through a material reverse termination fee. On T, we increased our target price to $14.50 (from $13.00) to reflect our view that there is a 25% probability of a transaction closing.” TD Cowen analyst Aaron Bilkoski thinks Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. ’s ( CNQ-T ) all-cash offer of $2.53-billion to acquire Advantage Energy Ltd. ( AAV-T ) represents “fair value” and recommends shareholders “crystallize value.” Accordingly, he moved his rating for Advantage to “sell” from “buy” previously. “Based on our current estimates and TD Cowen commodity deck, the offer equates to 5.0 times 2027 estimated DACF [debt-adjusted cash flow], consistent with Montney transactions averaging 5.0-times forward CF since 2023,” said Mr. Bilkoski. “Recall that AAV conducted a lengthy public process that ended without an acceptable outcome in early 2026. Given the 25-per-cent premium to Friday’s close and all-cash consideration, we believe a superior proposal is unlikely. “We recommend AAV shareholders sell their equity and reallocate proceeds to other potential consolidation targets in our coverage. With the consolidation trend continuing, we see better opportunities for capital than holding AAV shares through the expected Q1/27 close to capture only a small premium. We have previously highlighted KEL-T and SDE-T as the most likely acquisition targets in our coverage.” Mr. Bilkoski moved his target for Advantage shares to $13.55 from $14 to reflect the value of the offer. The average on the Street is $13.50. Elsewhere, National Bank’s Dan Payne moved his rating to “tender” from “outperform” with a $13.55 target, down from $14.50. “The announced acquisition outcome represents fair value for the company’s remaining Montney/Charlie Lake & Infrastructure assets, as evidenced by a strong implied multiple and associated premium, and we are moving our target price to $13.55 (from $14.50; based on the implied transaction value, from the prior 6.0 times 2027 estimated EV/DACF NBCCM estimate) and target to Tender (from Outperform) as a result. Residually, the consolidation cycle of similarly styled assets remains in full swing that is impossible to ignore, with remaining assets in the fairway (i.e., BIR & KEL) expected to continue to be re-rated in association with that expanding scarcity (with value upside to note in a similar range),” said Mr. Payne. Analysts making target revisions to Advantage shares include: * Raymond James’ Luke Davis to $13.55 from $12.50 with a “market perform” rating. “While we’ve long highlighted Advantage’s attractive liquids-rich development inventory, improving balance sheet and aggressive share buyback program, the ongoing CEO search and weaker natural gas pricing have presented near-term overhangs. As such, we view the cash deal as an attractive outcome for shareholders; that said, there could be pockets of investors looking for a little more upside given the longer-term development potential at Progress, Valhalla, Charlie Lake, and NEBC, though our base expectation is that the deal will ultimately be completed as announced. The transaction is expected to close in 1Q27, pending shareholder, court and regulatory approvals,” said Mr. Davis. * RBC’s Michael Harvey to $13.55 from $14 with a “sector perform” rating. “We view the offer as fair, and adjust our PT to $13.55/share to reflect this figure (previously $14). Given a full strategic review and (in our view) a fair price, we see the emergence of a competing bid as unlikely,” said Mr. Harvey. While the third-quarter results from Chemtrade Logistics Income Fund ( CHE.UN-T ) fell under expectations, National Bank Financial analyst Zachary Evershed thinks its “stable guidance amidst volatility is a win” for investors. “We view the maintained $505-million midpoint favourably given our concerns on near-term softer pricing in EC [electrochemicals],” he explained. “Implied Q4 guidance calls for $109-129-million in EBITDA, an 11-25-per-cent step down from Q3, less steep than historical seasonality at the midpoint. Stronger progress on CHE’s input cost inflation pass-throughs see us revise our estimates up, seeing Q4 EBITDA of $118.4-million (was $105.9-million) and 2026 EBITDA of $504.3-million (was $488.5-million).” In a client note titled Growth on tap , Mr. Evershed said he thinks the “early read on 2027 is positive” with a “favourable setup” for caustic. However, he warned “inflection timing [is] uncertain.” “Ahead of fulsome guidance to be released in early January, management provided their broad expectations for 2027: higher Adj. EBITDA, with higher volumes and margin expansion in Water Solutions, continued gains in Ultrapure driving an uptick in Acid and Sulphur Products, and a potential inflection in caustic pricing helping Electrochemicals,” he said. “While there has been significant volatility in Electrochemicals due to Asian producers flooding the caustic market, with electricity making up 70 per cent of caustic production costs and electricity costs creeping higher in Asia, management agrees with CMA forecasts that caustic pricing should begin to rise in the near future. Timing that recovery has proven difficult, but with Asian producers selling at or slightly below cash costs, the current slump is not sustainable. This is a favourable setup for CHE’s domestic production, given their stable, low-cost hydropower advantage.” After adjusting his forecast to reflect third-quarter results, the latest macro data points, commodity price movements and management remarks, Mr. Evershed raised his target for Chemtrade units to $23 from $22.50, keeping an “outperform” rating. The average target is $19.79. “Narrowed guidance maintaining the $505 million midpoint for 2026 was better than we hoped for, and with a positive outlook for 2027, upward revisions to our forecasts see our target nudge up to $23 (was $22.50) on an unchanged 7.0 times 2027 estimated EV/EBITDA, equivalent to a 5.9-per-cent FCF yield and replicated in our DCF using an 11.6-per-cent discount rate. Given a clear growth path and an attractive entry point at a 9.3-per-cent FCF yield, we reiterate our Outperform rating,” he concluded. TD Cowen analyst Sam Damiani sees H&R REIT ( HR.UN-T ) “setting a course to create a U.S.-focused apartment REIT” after its unitholders voted down a proposed $3.4-billion takeover by a consortium led by GO Residential Real Estate Investment Trust last week. “We see a brighter future ahead, despite a noisy Q3 with some further softening in sun belt apartment fundamentals,” he added. “With the prior proposed transaction now in the rearview mirror, H&R is pivoting to capitalize on the opportunity to become a high quality U.S.-focused apartment REIT. Execution is paramount, but we see attractive upside including the $2.30 special cash distribution” On Friday, H&R announced it is preparing to roll out an investor-friendly property sale strategy, selling individual properties or entire portfolios. It will also retroactively pay monthly dividends and intends to declare a special cash distribution of approximately $2.30 per unit before the end of the year. “Manaement reconfirmed the goal of completing the board refresh by year-end 2026,” said Mr. Damiani in a client note. “Management otherwise held off discussing potential changes in strategy until then, but did mention that the now-expired Arrangement Agreement no longer restricts the REIT’s disposition activities. The updated strategic vision no longer includes industrial properties and is now ‘to be a leading owner, operator and developer of residential properties’ in the GTA, U.S. sun belt, and gateway cities. “IFRS FV reductions appear to reflect conservative assumptions. H&R booked a $0.7-billion or 10-per-cent FV [fair value] loss on its income & development properties in Q3. Residential values were reduced to reflect higher concessions and a 30 basis points higher cap rate (now 5.03 per cent overall and 5.27 per cent for just sun belt states). Industrial was simply marked down to the prior contracted sale prices (even though we believe some could be sold for more today). The Two Gotham office property was valued under a DCF which assumes a probability of the main tenant (NYC Dept of Health) vacating even though they are described as a “sticky” tenant. (Their renewal exercise date is in 1.5 years.) All this reduced IFRS NAV by 15 per cent quarter-over-quarter to $13.83. We reduced our NAV estimate by 7 per cent to $13.70 (cap rate up 8 basis points and slightly lower NOI)." Despite “big” forecast adjustments to reflect the impact of the special distribution as well as its quarterly earnings miss, leading to drops in his 2027 and 2028 FFO/unit estimates of 6 per cent and 18 per cent, respectively, Mr. Damiani raised his target for H&R units to $11.50 from $11, keeping a “buy” rating. The average target is $11.21. “H&R’s primary strategic goal is now to become a pure-play apartment REIT, which we have been supporting over the past year,” he said. “Significant near-term execution is still required on the board refresh (and ultimately a CEO search) plus non-core dispositions. At a high level, we see improved potential at H&R for a brighter future ahead. We found the unitholder friendly changes announced following Friday’s meeting to be very encouraging. We look forward to further progress near term.” Analyst Graham Ryding continues to see “significant value” in Onex Corp. ( ONEX-T ) shares, naming it one of TD Cowen’s “Best Ideas” for 2027. “Management appears to be executing on three key initiatives (Convex, balance sheet reorientation, and FRE growth), though valuation remains compressed on a P/NAV basis,” he said. In a client report released Tuesday, Mr. Ryding updated his valuation methodology for the Toronto-based private equity investor and asset management firm, pointing to four “key” themes: * A constructive outlook for Convex, which was acquired in partnership with American International Group (AIG) last uear. Analyst: “This specialty P&C direct investment is adding welcome visibility into earnings within Onex’s NAV (43 per cent of NAV) ... We believe the current 2.0 times P/TBV valuation for Convex within NAV is defendable and in line with comparables.” * “Ongoing transition to an asset-lighter model.” Analyst: “Onex has agreed to sell interest in certain PE assets from ONCAP IV, OP V, and the Opportunities Fund in the secondaries market. The sale price was 92 per cent of the most recent mark, and is expected to generate proceeds of $334-million back to Onex. * Resumption of buybacks. Analyst: Onex resumed repurchases in Aug. 2026 following a pause since June 2025 (prior to the Convex deal announcement). For the 3 years prior to June 2025, Onex bought back shares at an annual rate of 7 per cent of s/o.“ * Fee-related earnings appear to be on pace to reach targeted run rate. Analyst: “FRE was $6-million in Q3/26, and management appears confident in achieving its target run rate of $35-million by Q1/27. A successful initial close for OP VI ($2-billion was raised) is supportive.” Maintaining his “buy” rating for Onex shares, Mr. Ryding raised his target to $170 from $165. The average is $155.20. In other analyst actions : * In a report titled All Dressed Up, Nowhere To Go... Yet , Raymond James’ Luke Davis downgraded Kelt Exploration Ltd. ( KEL-T ) to “market perform” from “outperform” previously, keeping a $13 target. The average is $13.45. “Following a pre-emptive reserve update last week combined with another regional Montney deal announced [Monday] morning, Kelt has traded up roughly 20 per cent in the last two sessions and is the top performer among peers, up more than 60 per cent year-to-date (vs. gas-weighted peers at 5 per cent and 12 per cent). While we still place the company near the top of our pecking order as it relates to potential takeouts, we think remaining upside is increasingly muted, while acknowledging strong operational momentum and plenty of portfolio optionality. With the stock now approaching our $13/share target price, we are downgrading KEL to Market Perform given a premium valuation and limited clarity on a potential monetization event,” said Mr. Davis * National Bank’s Alex Terentiew lowered his Americas Gold and Silver Corp. ( USA-T ) target by $1 to $10 with an “outperform” rating. The average on the Street is $11.82. “We lower our 2027/2028 EBITDA estimates by 12 per cent/4 per cent to US$144/254-million, respectively, and NAVPS by 7 per cent. While we expect much of Q3’s cost pressure to be non-recurring and related to development initiatives, we have raised Galena cost assumptions to reflect a slower normalization. With higher costs and silver prices under pressure, near-term headwinds could persist. However, we continue to see infrastructure progress supporting substantially higher production and lower costs beginning around mid-2027,” said Mr. Terentiew. * Mr. Terentiew also reduced his Contango Silver & Gold Inc. ( CTGO-T ) target to $39 from $41 with an “outperform” rating. The average is US$31.67. “For 2027, we trimmed Manh Choh grades and raised costs, reducing our 2027 EBITDA estimate to US$99-million and setting our AISC [all-in sustaining cost] forecast at US$1,640/oz (from US$1,400/oz). Q3 reflected higher rainfall, lower Fort Knox throughput and downtime for modifications to process higher-copper and higher-sulphide South Pit ore, rather than a mine-plan change,” he said. * Following weaker-than-anticipated third-quarter results, National Bank’s Baltej Sidhu reduced his Ballard Power Systems Inc. ( BLDP-Q , BLDP-T ) target to US$3, falling under the US$3.32 average, from US$4.50 with a “sector perform” rating, while Raymond James’ Fred Gatali cut his target to US$2.20 from US$3.50 with a “market perform” rating. “BLDP continues to execute, with greater margins, improving backlog and the GeoPura platform enhancing its growth profile. Execution consistency is the key barometer, that will require repeatability to de-risk visibility for its stated targets. On account of estimate revisions, we lower our target,” said Mr. Sidhu. * National Bank’s Mohamed Sidibe lowered his Endeavour Mining plc ( EDV-T ) target by $1 to $100 with an “outperform” rating. The average is $100.96. “Our 2026 production is mostly unchanged at 1,124 koz (1,127 koz prior), though now at an AISC of $1,834/oz ($1,870/oz prior) on the lower sustaining capex in Q3/26. Our model reflects the commentary on Q4/26 grades, throughput and recovery provided on each asset. Our 2026 capex decreases to $625-million ($654-million prior), with lower remaining cash-tax payments helping increase FCF 3 per cent to $1,631-million ($1,577-million prior). For 2027, our production is trimmed 4 per cent to 1,111 koz reflecting the lower Mana forecast, while AISC decreases 2 per cent to $1,900/oz ($1,938/oz prior) mostly on Mana accounting,” he said. * TD Cowen’s Steven Green raised his G Mining Ventures Corp. ( GMIN-T ) target to $70 from $66 with a “buy” rating, The average is $63.93. “We have updated our estimates post-Q3, incorporating an initial model for Gurupi [gold project in Brazil] into our NAV ($979-million), representing a meaningful addition to GMIN’s longer-term growth pipeline,” he said. “GMIN has several key catalysts ahead, including the updated Gurupi resource, Gurupi PEA, and updated technical report for the Oko district (mid-2027).”