Trump tells black reporter: ‘You never noticed broken windows’
Trump tells black reporter: You would not notice dirt or broken windows US president criticised over remark to Haitian-American journalist Lily Shanagher Foreign Breaking News Reporter Show biography Lily has reported on the Iran war, Latin America and domestic events. You can contact her at [email protected] or via X @lilyshanagher Published 17 November 2026 12:49pm GMT Donald Trump told a black reporter she had “never noticed broken windows” and did not “see dirt”. The US president criticised Yamiche Alcindor, a Haitian-American, telling her “you never noticed broken windows, obviously, from where you come” when the NBC News White House correspondent mentioned building work in Washington . Alcindor had asked: “What do you say to critics who say you were too focused on DC construction projects while our airline systems were crumbling?” She was referring to the four-hour national grounding of planes ordered by the US federal aviation administration last Friday, which led to worldwide travel disruption. “Well, if you take a look at the White House, it’s flawless,” Mr Trump retorted. The US National Association of Black Journalists has decried Mr Trump’s ‘disrespect, hostility and public denigration directed at black women journalists’ Credit : Getty Images/Chip Somodevilla “Listen to me: I know you don’t see dirt, but if you take a look at the White House, you never noticed broken windows, obviously, from where you come, I don’t know... We had 18 broken windows.” The US president called Alcindor “so pathetic” and a “loser” and said she had no talent. When she tried to ask a follow-up question, Mr Trump responded: “This doesn’t cost money. This is peanuts. I pay for it . This is called talent. You don’t have talent... When you see a broken column you don’t notice. “But when other leaders of state and other people come here – the White House was in terrible condition. Now it’s in beautiful condition.” Alcindor shared footage of the exchange on social media. ‘Disrespect and public denigration’ This was not the first time Mr Trump had targeted a black journalist for criticism. The National Association of Black Journalists earlier this year decried “the continued tone of disrespect, hostility and public denigration directed at black women journalists who are doing their jobs”, after Mr Trump insulted Rachel Scott, an ABC News reporter who had asked about his priorities amid the Iran war. Rachel Scott, of NBC News, was told by the US president: ‘You can understand dirt, maybe, better than I can’ Credit : Getty Images/Andrew Harnik “You can understand dirt, maybe, better than I can, but I don’t allow it,” the US president told Scott, after she had mentioned his alterations to the Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool . He said: “You probably don’t see dirt, but I do.” It was also not the first time he has sparred with Alcindor. Last year, he told her “listen” and “be quiet” when she asked him about a social media post in which he had written: “Chicago is going to learn why it’s called the department of war,” referring to his renamed defence ministry amid threats of sending the national guard into the city. Yamiche Alcindor, the NBC News White House correspondent, has been on the receiving end of Trump’s opprobrium before Credit : Getty Images/Shannon Finney When she asked him to explain his post, he responded: “When you say that, darling, that’s fake news... You never listen. That’s why you’re second-rate.” In 2020, he told her: “Be nice ... don’t be threatening” when she asked a question over his management of the coronavirus outbreak. The president told Catherine Lucey, the Bloomberg reporter, “ quiet, Piggy ” and called CNN’s Kaitlan Collins a “corrupt reporter” with “ hatred in her eyes ”. ‘Quiet, Piggy’, Mr Trump told Catherine Lucey of Bloomberg Alcindor was referring to the longest US national ground stop of aircraft since the 9/11 terrorist attacks, caused by an upgrade to a decades-old telecoms network. Sean Duffy, the US transportation secretary, said part of a key system allowing communication between air traffic controllers and pilots had been changed from copper to fibre-optic wiring . Thousands of flights were cancelled or delayed, with days of ripple effects across the world. On Sunday, Mr Trump blamed the issue on Joe Biden, the former US president, writing on Truth Social that his predecessor’s administration had made an “old and broken system worse than when they began”. He also called for the approval of funds for a new air traffic control system. “If Congress approves the desperately needed money for Air Traffic Control, we can get it built quickly and efficiently,” he wrote. “It will be the best system anywhere in the world. Much of our current air control system is 50 years old – ridiculous.”