Trans law ‘could lead to children being taken away from parents’
Tories say Labour’s proposed legislation could remove a child from families who do not use preferred pronouns Labour’s “draconian” conversion therapy bill will have a destructive effect on families, the shadow culture secretary has said. Rebecca Paul warned that, under the Conversion Practices Bill , if parents question whether their children are transgender , a local authority investigation could be triggered and “result in children being removed from parents”. The draft legislation includes a penalty of up to five years in prison for anyone who engages in abusive conversion practices that cause serious harm, alarm or distress. Campaigners warn that the wording is so broad that parents could face police investigation for asking their child whether they really want to change gender. The Telegraph is campaigning for the legislation to be scrapped amid concerns that it would have a chilling effect on the relationship between children and their parents . In her first interview since becoming shadow culture secretary in August , Ms Paul said: “You will have the situation where a child, a young person, could effectively say: ‘Well, if you don’t give me the money for those cross-sex hormones, or you don’t consent to let me on that puberty blocker trial, or you don’t use my pronouns, you’re causing me immense distress, and I’m going to report you to the police’. “I mean, that’s a situation where you’re in, and the moment there’s a criminal allegation as well, that would trigger a local authority investigation, and could – could – result in children being removed from parents. Ms Paul has claimed that children could be taken away from their parents if they refuse to use preferred pronouns or do not fund their hormone treatment. “Basically none of this has been thought through. It’s really amateur and low quality, and as I said before, the consequences, the negative consequences of the bill are just huge. It’s going to have a really destructive effect on families.” Campaigners have long called for conversion therapy to be made illegal Credit : SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images/Vuk Valcic The Telegraph’s campaign has been backed by Ms Paul and MPs across the political spectrum, as well as peers and experts. On Monday, Baroness Cass , who led a review into the treatment of children with gender dysphoria, withdrew her support for the bill. She warned that the proposed legislation, as currently drafted, would have “serious unintended consequences”. This, she said, could include medical professionals who worked in gender services being subject to vexatious complaints. Ms Paul said that the crossbencher peer’s views were damning for the legislation, adding: “There is no way that this bill can survive in its current form after Baroness Cass’s comments.” Labour MPs are also in revolt over the bill , with at least a dozen telling party whips that they are not happy with it in its current form. A number of ministers are said to have “grave concerns”. Tonia Antoniazzi, a Labour MP, said the legislation would have a chilling effect on parents trying to give advice to their children. She said: “I would urge the Prime Minister to step in and scrap this bill. “Mothers are often closest to their children – they need to be brave and strong and look after their children. If parents are criminalised and families divided, it is mothers who will be affected.” Labour MP Tonia Antoniazzi has urged the Prime Minister to scrap the bill Ms Paul also warned the Conversion Practices Bill could signal the end of single-sex spaces, adding that the legislation in its current form “is a disaster”. She said: “The advice will be: Oh, in order to avoid any risk of an offence, just don’t provide single-sex spaces, just make everything gender neutral. “Because if you provide a single-sex space and then say, actually, only women can access that space, there is a risk that that could trigger an offence. That’s how broad this bill is. “It’s drafted so broadly that it will encroach into family life and conversations that parents are having with their children.” She added: “The bill is incredibly draconian and will have a real chilling effect.” Ms Paul said she feared the bill, if it became law, would have a ‘chilling effect’ Credit : Paul Grover for The Telegraph Lord Glasman, founder of the influential Blue Labour movement, said: “Putting parents at risk of prosecution for trying to protect their children is something no Labour government should even consider.” Labour has been accused by Fiona McAnena, the director of campaigns at women’s rights group Sex Matters , of “massively overestimating” the scale of conversion therapy in the UK, after the Government refused to reveal the number of calls received by a helpline established for people to raise concerns about the issue. Four years ago, a Cabinet Office tender for an official hotline to report cases said the number of callers could be as high as 15,000 a year. However, another tender put out this summer stated that as few as 300 people a year may call. A government spokesman said the original helpline was the first of its kind, and as such there was no robust basis for estimating what quantity of calls to expect. Dr Lisa Morrison, the chief regulation and standards officer at the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy, told the draft conversion practices bill committee on Thursday that her organisation was “not aware of any complaints” about conversion practices. Helen Joyce, the director of advocacy at Sex Matters, said the bill could mean families were “destroyed”. She said: “A parent who seeks to convince a child that they aren’t actually a member of the opposite sex or ‘non-binary’ or some other exotic gender, like demi-boy or neutrois, is committing what the bill calls a ‘conversion practice’. “If the child complains to a teacher, the teacher will have to tell the police or else risk being accused of committing a crime themselves. “The police will have to tell the local authority, which will have to investigate whether the parent is a fit person to care for that child, and may well conclude that someone accused of a crime against a child so serious that it could lead to a five-year prison sentence cannot possibly be allowed to continue looking after that child or any other.” Helen Joyce said the implications of the proposed legislation could mean families were ‘destroyed’ Credit : AFP via Getty Images/JOHN MACDOUGALL Ms Joyce added: “If there is no other relative to care for those children, they will be taken into care. That family will be destroyed, no matter what happens eventually in court.” A government spokesman said: “The law is clear on protecting single-sex spaces and the government will always uphold this. “Parents reasonably challenging their child’s identity are not abusive conversion practices and are therefore completely out of the scope of our draft bill. “Successive governments have agreed for almost a decade that conversion practices have no place in modern Britain. “We have brought forward a draft bill for pre-legislative scrutiny in order to get this right and end almost a decade of delay for LGBT+ people who should never have to suffer abuse in an effort to change who they are.”