Tim Benz: Steelers’ home-road splits may be about a deeper issue

Maybe the 2026 Pittsburgh Steelers just stink on the road. There is mounting evidence to suggest this is the case. So far, the Steelers have played five games away from Acrisure Stadium. One of them was in Paris against the New Orleans Saints. That’s not a true road game. Forget that one. It was more of a neutral-site affair. One of them was a win against a 3-6 Tampa Bay Buccaneers team. The Steelers needed overtime to secure that victory against an undrafted, free-agent rookie quarterback (Jalon Daniels) by a final score of 26-19. The other three games were defeats in Cincinnati, New England and Cleveland. The loss to the Browns was 27-24 in a place where they always seem to lose. The other two were losses to the Bengals and Patriots by a combined 37 points. Mike McCarthy’s offensive unit is only averaging 17.7 points per game in those four true road games. “We need to play better on the road,” McCarthy acknowledged Monday. “Especially on offense. Our gap between offensive performance on the road and at home is too wide.” Offensive coordinator Brian Angelichio attempted to add more texture to the split between the offensive production on the road versus at home. The Steelers offense is posting a much more respectable 27.7 points per game in the Steelers’ four home wins in four tries. “Crowd noise is a part of it, playing on the road — timing, motions, rhythm, snap count, protection adjustments. That all goes into it because there’s so much communication that goes in on third downs,” Angelichio said. “It’s a lot easier to do at home. But I think we just haven’t been able to get into a rhythm — start fast. You saw it (Sunday). We need to get that flow. We need to stack plays. We need to hit some chunks and just gain that confidence. That’s what we haven’t had, and that’s something that we’re continuing to look at.” More sports • First Call: Steelers DC Patrick Graham admits being behind Bengals coach Zac Taylor; is Jaromir Jagr finally ready to retire? • McCormick’s injury opens door for Anderson to start on Steelers offensive line • The Penguins want to be more physical on defense. But what does that look like? This isn’t an offense-only conversation. Steelers coordinator Patrick Graham has seen his defensive unit yield just 17 points per game at home. It gives up 26 on the road. “You want to start faster on the road. We didn’t do a good enough job getting (Cincinnati) to third downs. We lost the battle on early downs, which is tough against those teams,” Graham said. “You want to try to force them into third down, where I think the menu is limited by them a little bit. We didn’t do a good enough job of that.” All of that seems problematic, and it needs to be fixed, seeing as how the Steelers still have to travel for games in Jacksonville, Nashville and Baltimore. All of those visits follow Sunday’s game in Philadelphia, a place where Pittsburgh hasn’t won since 1965. “I don’t know. We’ll look at that,” quarterback Aaron Rodgers said of the Steelers road woes after losing in Cincinnati. Here’s a theory that may be worse: What if this isn’t a road-home problem at all? What if there is more to this? What if this isn’t about location and this is about the quality of the opponent? Again. If you recall, last year the Steelers were 10-8, counting their playoff loss to the Houston Texans. The only victory of those 10 against a playoff team was in New England in Week 2. Of those losses, six were against teams in the playoffs. The Steelers could beat the bad teams, and they lost to the good teams. It could be that we are starting to see the same thing in 2025. The Steelers’ three losses have all come against teams currently at or above .500 — New England, Cincinnati and Cleveland. Four of their six wins have come against sub .500 competition — Tampa Bay, New Orleans, Atlanta and Indianapolis. So I suppose they’ve shown a little bit more of an ability to beat a potential playoff club by knocking off the two teams from Ohio once apiece. Splitting their series with the Browns and Bengals means McCarthy’s players can claim at least two wins already against teams currently in a playoff spot. The Bengals should be such a club by season’s end. I’m still unsure about the Browns. The Steelers have eight games remaining over the back half of the schedule. Four of them are road contests — at Philadelphia, Jacksonville, Tennessee and Baltimore. They only have two games remaining against clubs currently above .500 — Denver at home on Nov. 27 (Black Friday) and at Jacksonville (“Monday Night Football”) on Dec. 14. So, on the one hand, that seems beneficial to the Steelers. Then again, the Bengals and Browns have similar schedules. And what happens if the Steelers have to go on the road as a wild card again to face the likes of the Bengals, Broncos, Chiefs, Jaguars or Bills in the first round of the playoffs? Based on their last four road playoff games in New England, Buffalo, K.C. and Baltimore dating back to 2016, I think we have a pretty good idea. They lost all four of those contests by a combined score of 137-69. And none of them felt that close. The Steelers now have eight regular season games and at least one playoff contest to prove they are a different club under McCarthy in Year 1 than they were under Tomlin in Year 19. Thus far, we are seeing a significant resemblance regardless of where the games are played.