The man skating on the horrible state of Dallas Cowboys defense isn’t the GM

As the owner and the GM of the team, Jerry Jones likes to say he has the final say, which means ultimately the state of the Dallas Cowboys are his responsibility — but he has “help.” The current state of this team is on him, as well as head coach Brian Schottenheimer, defensive coordinator Christian Parker, and somewhere in this matrix of blame is someone who must raise his hand, too. Will McClay can’t escape this one. The long time Cowboys’ director of player personnel has to take his fair share of “the fun” for what is slowly becoming just another painful season of hype and some expectations turned into a thunderous thud of the same damn thing. The Cowboys’ defeat on Sunday against the San Francisco 49ers at Levi’s Stadium East was another “It can’t get any worse than this” loss this season. Scheme and coaching are culprits, a point that former Cowboys linebacker Leighton Vander Esche pointed out on Monday on social media. During 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey’s 66-yard touchdown reception with 3:23 remaining in the game, he was “covered” by Cowboys linebacker Von Miller. Miller is 37, done, and he was assigned to cover McCaffrey. “Absolute horrendous play call,” Vander Esche wrote on his Instagram account. “Zero reason to have a D-end in coverage late in the game, let alone vacate the whole middle of the field (by himself) on the best receiving back in the league.” A lot of these players on defense are simply not good enough to be starters in the NFL, and probably not backups, either. Players McClay picked. Current state of Dallas Cowboys defensive personnel One way to evaluate a roster is to project if other teams would sign your guys if they were suddenly available. The Dallas Cowboys offensive players, nearly all of whom McClay picked or wanted, would be starting if they were available to the other 31 NFL teams. Even backups, such as lineman T.J. Bass, would have no problem finding a job elsewhere. A few of the defensive players, nearly all of whom McClay picked or wanted, would be starters elsewhere with no hesitation. Defensive tackle Quinnen Williams, corner back Joey Porter Jr. - both of whom were acquired via trade — as well as rookie first round pick Caleb Downs would start for any other team in the NFL. Defensive tackle Kenny Clark and rush linebacker Rashan Gary would be on other teams, but they would be role and situational players. Linebacker DeMarvion Overshown is a nice player, but the man can’t stay healthy. Young players such as Donovan Ezeiruaku and Otito Ogbonnia have shown promise, but neither would be moved in exchange for a first or second round pick. The rest would have a hard time joining a starting lineup, and many may just land on a practice squad or wait around in hopes of a phone call. That’s a terrible indictment on the talent level. Cowboys’ staffers affected by the final The Cowboys have seven games remaining, and the way Schottenheimer talked after the loss to the 49ers, and again on Monday afternoon, his defensive coordinator is essentially on notice. Whatever praise and optimism that rained on Parker has evaporated in yet another horrible performance by the Cowboys’ defense. Barring a miracle finish to this season, someone of significance with the Cowboys will be fired. As much as Jerry Jones may like some of these people, he’s not getting any younger, and he can’t stomach the thought of yet another repeat year like this mess. Even though this is only Schottenheimer’s second season as the head coach, and he’s halfway through his four-year contract, moving on from Schottenheimer is rational. Even though this is Parker’s first season as a defensive coordinator, and the Cowboys keep changing out this position with little success, moving on from Parker looks almost inevitable. The defense was not good in Week 1, and not only is it not improving, but it’s regressing. Which leaves McClay, who has been a loyal member of this team’s personnel department since 2002; he started to oversee the draft process with the team in 2014, and was elevated to position of Director of Player Personnel in 2017. He signed a five-year contract extension in January 2025. As the Cowboys churn through new defensive coordinators, his task is to find guys to fit the preferences of the new coach. Changing out d-coordinators year after year makes that task difficult, but the Cowboys may not have to churn through so many defensive coaches if the players were a little better. McClay has respect around the league, and would work 27 hours a day if possible. A lot of his draft picks, and “guys,” are hits, especially fourth-round selection Dak Prescott. But from its scheme to its talent, this defense is a mess, and McClay has to own his part, too. Jerry is the final say of the Dallas Cowboys, but in this season he’s had a lot of help. Mac Engel Fort Worth Star-Telegram 817-390-7760 Mac Engel is an award-winning columnist who has covered sports since the dawn of man; Cowboys, TCU, Stars, Rangers, Mavericks, etc. Olympics. Movies. Concerts. Books. He combines dry wit with 1st-person reporting to complement an annoying personality. Support my work with a digital subscription