Panthers’ penchant for penalties has them on pace to break a pair of dubious NFL records
CHARLOTTE, N.C. — David Tepper didn’t love the message posted outside of Dilworth Neighborhood Grille the first night of the NFL draft two years ago. But the sports bar a mile from Bank of America Stadium often accurately captures the day-after mood of Carolina Panthers fans on its aging sign during the season. A day after flags flew at a record pace for the Panthers at the Caesars Superdome, Charlotte commuters on Monday were greeted with this musing from the restaurant’s owner: “20 POINTS, 17 PENALTIES EQUALS FIRST PLACE.” Carolina survived 17 penalties for 152 yards — both single-game, franchise highs — to beat the New Orleans Saints 20-17 on Sunday and grab sole possession of first in the NFC South. The Panthers became just the 13th team in NFL history to win on the road when called for 17 penalties or more. Also notable: Carolina won despite a staggering 17-to-3 disparity in accepted penalties. “I feel like if we’d played a cleaner game as far as penalties, it wouldn’t have even been close,” outside linebacker Princely Umanmielen said. Mindful of potential fines, Panthers players and coach Dave Canales were careful not to be too critical when discussing the officiating. The NFL juggled its Week 10 crews following Friday’s FAA ground stop, reassigning officials to games within driving distance of their residences. Duane Heydt, an umpire since 2022, was the referee for Sunday’s game in New Orleans. Top Plays from Panthers @ Saints Penalties have been a problem all season for the Panthers, who established a team record for penalty yards (149) in a Week 6 road win against the Philadelphia Eagles, only to break it again four weeks later against the Saints. The Panthers have had three games with at least 13 penalties, are the league’s most-penalized team and are on pace to break the NFL records for penalties (163) and penalty yards (1,358), set by the Oakland Raiders in 2011 over a 16-game schedule. Carolina would finish with 164 penalties and 1,487 penalty yards at its current pace. Through nine games, the Panthers have already surpassed their penalty yardage total from 2025, when they ranked among the league’s least-penalized teams. “It feels like there’s a bounty out for the Panthers or something. It’s ridic — I don’t know,” Umanmielen said. “Obviously, we could be more disciplined as a team. It’s frustrating, especially with the pre-snap penalties. It’s just a matter of discipline.” Canales spent 13 years as an assistant for the Seattle Seahawks, who were annually among the NFL’s penalty leaders and were the most-penalized team during their Super Bowl season of 2013. Former Seattle coach Pete Carroll considered some of the flags as the cost of the Seahawks’ aggressiveness. That attitude is shared by Canales, who doesn’t have a problem with “competitive, aggressive” penalties. “If you’re not getting penalized at all, you’re not playing hard enough,” Canales said. “What I’m talking about is pre-snap. I’m talking about post-snap. Those are the things that we have to figure out, that we have to clean up. And there are things that we’re working (on) to do that.” Panthers penalized: Under Canales YEAR PENALTIES YARDS NOTE *2026 87 787 Leads league in both categories 2025 95 762 tied-4th fewest (PEN); 7th fewest (YDS) 2024 118 947 8th most (PEN); 9th most (YDS) * Through nine games Sunday’s game started with Ryan Fitzgerald sailing the opening kickoff out of bounds for a penalty. It ended on Fitzgerald’s game-winning 54-yard field goal, which was set up by a pass interference penalty against the Saints, one of the few calls that went the Panthers’ way. In between, the Panthers were whistled for seven pre-snap penalties, including four encroachment or neutral-zone infractions on defense. The five personal fouls assessed against the Panthers included judgment calls on a horse-collar tackle by Jaelan Phillips on a sack of Tyler Shough and an unnecessary roughness penalty against linebacker Devin Lloyd. “It’s just unfortunate. There’s a lot of things I could say. There’s a lot of things that people could speculate when it comes to that,” Lloyd said. “But at the end of the day, we’ve gotta look at the ones that are self-inflicted and make sure they don’t happen.” The usually calm Canales became a little worked up after a second-quarter holding call on Panthers center Luke Fortner negated a Chuba Hubbard touchdown. “Some of those judgment calls, I got a little frustrated just because I want our guys to be able to play physical and be aggressive, and not have to worry about those types of things,” he said. Canales wondered whether some of the offside calls were the result in the more attacking style of interim defensive coordinator Todd Wash, who wants the defensive linemen getting upfield rather than reading and reacting. Canales is considering having the scout team offense use different snap counts this week against the defense. But defensive tackle Derrick Brown, who had one of the neutral-zone penalties, said players should know better. “We’ve played long enough,” Brown said. “From the time you’re in Little League, you can’t jump offsides. It just is what it is.” As Umanmielen indicated with his “bounty” comment, it could be that the Panthers’ reputation precedes them. They’ve had 30 penalties assessed against them the past two weeks against New Orleans and Denver, tied for the 10th-highest total in a two-game span since at least 1944. But cornerback Marco Wilson showed it’s possible to improve in the flag department. Wilson drew three pass interference calls and a taunting penalty against the Broncos, but was not among the many offenders in New Orleans. “Just like going against your opponent, you kind of know what to expect, now the refs know that we’ve been penalized a good amount. So we’re being very conscious moving forward that obviously that’s what they see on film and we’re gonna have to clean some stuff up, me especially,” Wilson said. “I had a game where I had a few penalties. So I just worked on the next week, coming in and figuring out what I did wrong and how I could eliminate those things.”