Opinion | Sean Duffy’s FAA failures show experience still matters
Many Americans would love to hear two things from the federal government after a major, disruptive incident like last week’s nationwide ground stop : Here’s what went wrong and here’s how we’re going to fix it. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy blitzed the five major Sunday morning political shows this week — and struggled to deliver either. Duffy couldn’t effectively provide either a cause or solution to the issues at the Federal Aviation Administration, laying bare his lack of experience with the issues his own department is supposed to manage. It’s part and parcel of the Trump administration’s broader dismissal of pretty much anyone who actually knows what they’re doing in favor of sycophants and people Trump thinks look good on TV. On NBC’s “Meet the Press” on Sunday, Duffy refused to apologize for the more than four-hour-long incident that led to days of disruptions. “It happened on my watch but we have to be clear: I am moving at an incredible speed that no one has done at the FAA or in decades, and I’m proud of the work we’re doing, the attention we’re bringing to this issue,” he told host Kristen Welker. He likewise told CNN’s Dana Bash : “I take responsibility for what was given to me by prior administrations.” It’s part and parcel of the Trump administration’s broader dismissal of pretty much anyone who actually knows what they’re doing in favor of sycophants and people Trump thinks look good on TV. It’s true that the FAA’s outdated systems have been in desperate need of modernization for decades now, but President Donald Trump, as is his wont , went further in dodging blame. Trump’s knee-jerk reaction to cast blame on the Biden administration whenever a federal government agency fails on his watch seems to come from a place of insecurity. People expect competent leaders to know how to fix their mistake — or at least get the ball rolling. The alternative is to be seen as unable or unwilling to clean up your own mess and for an administration that values optics and narrative over everything, that simply won’t do. The fault then must lay elsewhere. “The Biden administration was an FAA disaster. Everything they touched turned bad,” he wrote on Truth Social, adding, “Our FAA is doing a great job, and is ready to go.” Trump ignored the fact that he was president for four years before Biden and didn’t fix what needed fixing either. He has also been back in the White House for almost two years, displaying a continued lack of urgency on FAA modernization, even during a spike in near-misses and other incidents at airports around the country. Journalist James Fallows recently reported in The New York Times Magazine that, since last year, the Trump administration has shed several of the layers of redundancy that make air travel safe, including by disbanding several expert advisory panels. Even seemingly minor acts, like the FAA changing the international identifier of the newly renamed Donald J. Trump International Airport in Florida, add another layer of potential failure to an already precarious system. And there’s been plenty of people who know better who would happily tell Duffy the same. Duffy is one of many Cabinet members including Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, Education Secretary Linda McMahon and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. who lack expertise in the complex issues in their portfolios and undermine , fire or otherwise denigrate the work of staffers and other advisers who have built up institutional knowledge. But just why an upgrade from copper wiring to fiber-optic cable at one remote facility could overwhelm the nation’s air traffic control systems, as Duffy claimed Saturday, may be more on him than he’s been willing to admit. MS NOW has reported that according to sources, including a senior FAA official, it may have been the administration’s efforts to update the system too quickly that prompted the issue with radar systems nationwide. The goal of finishing the upgrade during Trump’s term has clashed with the difficult process of converting delicate, critical systems, as last week’s outage has shown. The Government Accountability Office also said in a report published in September that the FAA was “buying delivery speed at the risk of cost uncertainty and potential disruptions.” Duffy had no real answer when confronted with that report by host Margaret Brennan on CBS’ “Face the Nation.” We’re left with Duffy both struggling to suggest either a fully credible diagnosis or prognosis. It’s also odd that despite these rush jobs, the Department of Transportation has reportedly spent only $1 billion of the $12.5 billion in funds for upgrades the Republican-controlled Congress approved last year. A deeper series of investments in long-term fixes may have been possible if Duffy was more personally invested in the matter and better informed to effectively steer the modernization project. Instead, we’re left with Duffy both struggling to suggest either a fully credible diagnosis or prognosis. His criticism of the Biden administration likewise comes across as petulant whining. Maybe if Duffy had any sort of previous knowledge about the $1 trillion industry he oversees , he could be forgiven for choosing to do away with expertise in the department. Without that background, it seems irresponsible at best, dangerous at worst, and has made the odds of a disaster on the runway or in the skies much more likely. Trump’s political appeal lies largely in grievance politics, but it’s somewhat forgotten that when he first launched his presidential campaign in 2015, his pitch was that the country needed a hypercompetent, quick-on-his-feet man of action like the mostly fictitious version of himself he played on “The Apprentice.” After six years as president, it’s plain to see that management — especially crisis management — is just not his strength. Hayes Brown Hayes Brown is a writer and editor for MS NOW. He focuses on policymaking at the federal level, including Congress and the White House.