‘Oh my God, he’s next’: How Chris Vargas became the top quarterback prospect in Massachusetts history

“I never really thought these things happen to high school football players,” he says. “It’s pretty surreal.” To be clear, these things rarely happen to high school football players. But Vargas is considered the most highly touted quarterback prospect in New England history. Get Varsity News Your weekly look at the top high school sports stories. Enter Email The Lawrence native has committed to Ohio State , worked out with NFL stars, and now films commercials for a global sportswear brand. This season he has thrown for 1,820 yards and 21 touchdowns with just two interceptions, and his team has won every game. The top-seeded Eagles will face Springfield Central in a MIAA Division 1 state semifinal Friday. Vargas wants to change the perception that this region cannot produce elite quarterbacks, and he wants to become the first player of Dominican descent to achieve NFL greatness. It might sound ambitious for a 17-year-old whose boyish face makes him look even younger, but he intends to remove all doubts. Chris Vargas with his parents, Wascar and Massiel, and little brother Christian. Lane Turner/Globe Staff During his recruitment of Vargas, Boston College coach Bill O’Brien, who became familiar with good quarterback play when he was Tom Brady’s position coach with the Patriots, echoed sentiments of other admirers. “He said he thinks he’s the best he’s ever seen at this age in terms of his stature in the pocket, his footwork, how effortlessly the ball comes out of his hand,” St. John’s Prep coach Brian St. Pierre said. “He was just like, ‘I don’t think I’ve ever seen a kid at this level, at this age, do it like him.’ ” ‘What the hell was that?’ Vargas’s parents, Wascar and Massiel, are the children of immigrants from the Dominican Republic. When Wascar joined the football team at Lawrence High, he did not even know the rules. The couple signed up Chris for a Pop Warner league when he was 6. Older boys were throwing the ball around at the first practice when an errant toss landed near his feet. Chris picked it up and fired a dart across the field. “I was just looking, like, ‘What the hell was that?’ ” Wascar Vargas said, chuckling. Chris Vargas playing Pop Warner football in 2022 in Lawrence. Bryan Thomas/Mobile Magic His teammates that season told him he threw the ball too hard. Wascar, who started wearing gloves for their games of catch, probably agreed. At 10, Vargas led Lawrence to the Pop Warner national championship game in Florida. He soon started training with specialized coaches and persuaded them to let him work out with other clients who played in college. After Vargas finished seventh grade at a Lawrence charter school, his family began searching for a private school with a powerful football program. He had attended summer camps run by St. Pierre, the St. John’s Prep coach who was a star quarterback at Boston College before an eight-year career as an NFL backup. Chris and Wascar met with St. Pierre at St. John’s Prep , a 119-year-old all-boys academy on a sprawling tree-lined campus in Danvers. As they sat in a school chapel, St. Pierre, a St. John’s alum, explained how the program’s pro-style offense would prepare Chris for higher levels. Wascar told Chris to share what he had said during the drive to Danvers, but Chris was shy. St. Pierre asked Wascar to tell him. “He said he wants to come here because he wants to break every one of your records,” the father said. “I would love to have him do that,” St. Pierre responded, “and I’ll help him.” Chris Vargas came to St. John's Prep wanting to break the school records of his coach, Brian St. Pierre. Matthew J. Lee/Globe Staff ‘Oh my God, he’s next’ In 2023, a UConn assistant coach visited St. John’s Prep and asked St. Pierre if there were potential prospects in the Eagles’ pipeline. St. Pierre said he had a once-in-a-generation rising eighth-grader. “He was like, ‘We’re not talking to an eighth-grader,’ ” St. Pierre said. “I said, ‘I know, but he’s coming to your camp soon, and I have a feeling you’re going to call me.’ ” That summer, Vargas attended a one-day camp at UConn. His throws were crisp and precise, and he ended the day with a beautiful deep ball for a touchdown. Afterward, Huskies coaches pulled Vargas and his parents aside and offered a scholarship. “I honestly didn’t even know what it meant at that point,” Vargas said. The UConn assistant called St. Pierre and said he had been right about this wunderkind. Back at the family’s three-bedroom apartment in Lawrence, Wascar and Massiel Vargas were in shock. They sat at their dining room table and vowed not to let the recruiting process overwhelm their young son. In the ensuing weeks Vargas attended camps at Boston College, Penn State, UMass, and Rhode Island. Each school offered him a scholarship. Vargas had never even played at a level above Pop Warner. “I was like, ‘OK, what’s going on here?’ ” Wascar Vargas said. “These guys, this is what they do for a living. They recognize talent. And they’re offering him scholarships as an eighth-grader?” Eighth-graders at St. John’s Prep are ineligible to play varsity football, so St. Pierre told Vargas he could practice with the varsity all year or play for the middle school team, even if that option was not ideal. “He would have killed someone with a pass,” St. Pierre said. Vargas chose the varsity and became the scout-team quarterback, responsible for mimicking the opponent’s offense each week. But St. Pierre knew he also was the program’s future, so formations and schemes from the St. John’s playbook were added for Vargas anyway. “He’d make throws in practice, and everyone would be like, ‘Oh, my God. He’s next,’ ” St. Pierre said. “You’d hear the ball go by and it’s like, ‘That’s not how it always sounds, fellas.’ ” This season, Chris Vargas (2) has thrown for 1,820 yards and 21 touchdowns with just two interceptions for undefeated St. John's Prep. Matthew J. Lee/Globe Staff A courtship begins Vargas said he has never been hit harder than during his varsity debut against Marshfield as a freshman in 2024. Unbothered, he threw for 17 touchdowns and three interceptions that season and rocketed up recruiting boards. No longer a secret, elite Division 1 programs swarmed. His parents bought him a second cellphone to make communicating with coaches less daunting. He would return calls and texts from recruiters for a half-hour each night, then put the phone away. Suitors soon included USC, UCLA, Miami, Texas A&M, Oregon, and Virginia Tech. But Ohio State, which had offered Vargas a scholarship when he attended a camp there before his freshman season, was the clear favorite. Vargas took four unofficial visits to Columbus and felt a connection to coach Ryan Day, partly because conversations weren’t just sales pitches. Day is from Manchester, N.H., and played quarterback at the University of New Hampshire. They talked about familiar New England pizza shops and the Patriots. Chris Vargas wore a No. 12 Tom Brady Patriots jersey to a preseason game in 2019. Wascar Vargas Vargas attended a Michigan-Ohio State game, was introduced to a restaurant that served the best chicken wings he’s ever had, and felt at home on the bucolic campus. A devout Catholic who keeps a Bible on his nightstand, Vargas even appreciated that some Buckeyes players studied Scripture together. When he returned for a seven-on-seven tournament last year, Ohio State coaches were a presence at his games. They commended good throws and offered advice after bad ones. “I think deep down he felt that that was where he needed to be,” Massiel Vargas said. “He just moved so comfortably there.” This past summer, Wascar and Massiel Vargas were watching television in the Salem, N.H., home they moved into three years ago when Chris walked in and said he wanted to become a Buckeye. Day was golfing when Vargas called; upon receiving the news, he threw a club into the air and screamed with joy. A brand name Agents began contacting Wascar Vargas when Chris was in eighth grade, but the family rebuffed overtures. Last year, when Vargas was a sophomore, the family hired Los Angeles-based Athletes First to represent him. Once Ohio State emerged as the preferred choice last summer, agent David Mulugheta negotiated a name, image, and likeness (NIL) deal with the Buckeyes’ general manager. There was familiarity between the sides because Athletes First also represents Day. “We felt like Chris was making a good decision,” Mulugheta said. “We just wanted to make sure he was happy and going to get everything he deserved as far as a financial package. ... We were able to put something together that makes sense for the university and makes sense for Chris.” The terms of Vargas’s deal have not been disclosed, but a source familiar with the college football NIL landscape said five-star quarterback prospects can command as much as $2 million per season. Vargas’s partnership with Athletes First already has created new opportunities. The agency represents Green Bay Packers quarterback Jordan Love and Houston Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud, and this past summer Vargas worked out with them in Los Angeles. “We started throwing, and I was blown away,” Love said. “Like, he’s really, really talented. ... He’s far ahead of where I was at that age.” Chris Vargas this past summer worked out in Los Angeles with Green Bay Packers quarterback Jordan Love. David Mulugheta Love and Stroud gave Vargas autographed jerseys and they exchanged numbers. Vargas occasionally texts them for advice. About two years ago, before Vargas had an agent, New Balance global sports marketing director Naveen Lokesh saw highlights of the young quarterback on Instagram and was intrigued. The company started a gradual courtship by sending cleats and gear, and a member of the sports marketing team attended St. John’s Prep games. After about eight months, Vargas and his family met with New Balance executives at the global headquarters in Boston and visited the Lawrence factory, which employs more than 300 people and produces about 3,000 pairs of sneakers a day. This regional connection appealed to Vargas. New Balance is exploring refurbishing a football field in Lawrence as part of its commitment to him. When the sides discussed the recent commercial shoot, Vargas was resolute about filming in his hometown and including his family. “If he’d told us he wanted to shoot it on top of the Empire State Building, we would try to go do that,” Lokesh said. “But he made a point, ‘I want to do it here so my family can come, too.’ We thought that was pretty cool.” Vargas’s best friend is his 5-year-old brother, Christian, who is on the autism spectrum. When Chris returns from football practice each night, Christian starts yelling his name once he hears the garage door open. “And Christian is the first person Christopher goes up to to hug and kiss,” Massiel says. Chris Vargas’s best friend is his 5-year-old brother, Christian, who has autism. Lane Turner/Globe Staff Chris recently spotted Christian watching Ohio State football highlights on his tablet alone. On many nights, they chase each other around and mimic football snaps before Chris playfully tackles his little brother onto the couch. Is he the answer? College coaches cannot publicly comment on prospects until they officially sign, but Ohio State’s staff has made clear to Vargas that he is an essential part of their future. The Buckeyes, who won the 2024 national championship , have failed to meet their lofty standards this season. They are 6-3, and their near-term quarterback situation is unsettled. But 247Sports scouting director Andrew Ivins believes Vargas, the consensus No. 2 overall prospect in the class of 2028 behind Georgia commit Jayden Wade, has the highest ceiling of any signal-caller in the mix. “Chris should be viewed right now as Ohio State’s long-term answer,” Ivins said. St. John's Prep's Chris Vargas wants to change the perception that this region cannot produce elite quarterbacks. Winslow Townson for The Boston Globe But college remains almost two years away, and Vargas wants to leave his mark in Massachusetts first. Despite a recent uptick in regional talent, including Tabor Academy senior and Virginia Tech commit Peter Bourque , there remains a perception that New England is no quarterback factory. “People say, ‘Oh this kid’s from Massachusetts, he must not be good enough,’ ” Vargas said. “It feels really good to prove them wrong.” Vargas knows that for now, the hype surrounding him is based on potential. Former Natick High star Doug Flutie was a less-heralded recruit but went on to win the 1984 Heisman Trophy at Boston College and had a successful pro career, becoming the most accomplished quarterback in the region’s history. By comparison, Vargas has not done much yet. Last season he injured his left knee on a hit at the start of the state playoffs and was limited when he returned for the Super Bowl. He completed just 10 of 25 passes with two interceptions in a 41-35 loss to Xaverian . But Vargas has been in command this season. When he was younger and his coordination had yet to catch up with his growing frame, his friends joked that he moved like a baby deer. Now, his elegant footwork meshes with his powerful right arm. St. Pierre said one of Vargas’s lone flaws is the belief he can make every throw, no matter how daring. Vargas knew the spotlight would brighten after his college decision, and that some would root for him to fail. After rare wobbly passes, opposing student sections have showered him with “overrated” chants. Some opponents have tried to send a message by popping him after the whistle. “When you’re as high-profile as he is and commit to Ohio State, this is what you sign up for,” St. Pierre said. “It’s only going to intensify, and he knows that.” But Vargas embraces his growing fame, too. Over the summer he was riding a ski lift in North Conway, N.H., when teenagers going the other way recognized him and called out his name. St. John’s star wideout Riley Selvais said that when he brought Vargas to a high school game in Marblehead, his hometown, the student section was “in awe.” And last month, groups of fans took pictures with him at a Zach Bryan concert at Gillette Stadium. “I’ve signed a lot of shoes and phone cases,” Vargas said, smiling. Massiel Vargas, who works in the Lawrence Public School system, said her favorite moments at St. John’s games come at the end, when about 50 children line up for her son’s autograph. No matter the size of the crowd, Vargas signs for each one while his biggest fan, Christian, waits patiently to wrap himself around his big brother’s legs. Adam Himmelsbach can be reached at [email protected] . Follow him @adamhimmelsbach .