Milburn is ignoring the real answer to this crisis
In communist East Germany, there was no unemployment. Or rather, it was forbidden to say that anyone was unemployed. Everyone had a “job” in the authorised sense of the word, and everyone was paid in the official state currency. The prevailing national joke was: “We pretend to work and they pretend to pay us.” When communism collapsed, its currency was so valueless that the new state of unified Germany had to exchange it at an artificially inflated price that was equal to the West’s Deutschmark. You can only maintain a fiction of gainful employment for so long. When politicians invent jobs in order to employ people who must be paid, directly or indirectly, by the state, they are undermining the logic of their economy. It has been clear from the start that Alan Milburn’s project would not save money even though it would (hopefully) take people out of benefit dependency. That shift in the objective of the spending could be thought to be worthwhile in the long run. You would be paying people to look for work, or to train for it, rather than simply to be idle. But what would they be looking and training for? Jobs that no longer exist? There is much talk about the contraction of employment in the hands-on hospitality and retail sector, but that is quite easy to solve: just reverse all the absurd legislation that now makes it prohibitively expensive and risky to hire young, inexperienced people. The real crisis is in the lower ranks of business life and the professions: the junior and clerical levels of management which used to initiate entrants into fields which would provide careers. Many of those jobs are actually disappearing as the tasks that once provided invaluable direct working experience are being done by AI . By the time business leaders discover that there is a unique dimension to the human perspective, and an invaluable contribution made by young recruits to their workforce, it will be too late. A generation will have been lost and what they might have contributed to the workplace will be forever unknown. Janet Daley What might be the real answer to this crisis? This generation may have produced an epidemic of welfare dependency but something else has emerged as well. There is a new breed of entrepreneurial young people who, having found themselves closed out of existing cyber ventures because of their fatal “lack of experience”, are going it alone. They are developing ingenious new ways to apply the technological expertise which they and their peers have been developing since toddlerhood. It is opportunity and freedom from artificial limitations that they need: not government subsidy but liberation from the limits and burdens that government imposes on business in the name of “social fairness”. How about this? Instead of creating fake non-jobs which the Government pays for, give tax breaks and relief from employment protection regulations to start-ups launched by anyone under a given age. Rather than offer tech training schemes which are almost certain to be out of date before they are launched, reward the innovative use of tech by new entrants to the field with incentives to corporations to adopt them. Encourage real economic growth, not the synthetic kind that is subsidised by the state, by incentivising the expansion of new enterprises which want to expand but are afraid to incur legal liabilities. Stop thinking up new ways to interfere in business. Just get out of the way, and let youthful energy have its chance. You might be amazed at how much of it there is out there.