Leavitt too high, Stockton too low and 8 other regrets from our preseason QB rankings

It’s mid-November, essentially the fourth quarter of the college football regular season. With 10 regular-season games in the books, we know what these players are and we know what they’re not. Some preseason takes have aged well. And some have aged, umm, not so well. Our 2026 College Quarterback Tiers was one big preseason take. Now that there’s almost an entire regular season in the books, it’s time to self-scout and acknowledge where we could improve. This week, it’s time to examine our biggest regrets from our preseason QB ranking. 1. Not making more of Sam Leavitt’s issues LSU’s been one of the most expensive disappointments in college football. It’s not all on Leavitt (preseason rank No. 8), but he’s certainly played a critical role in the Tigers’ struggles. After a three-interception game against Texas, Leavitt is tied for the national lead with 12 picks this season. When evaluating Leavitt, who transferred from Arizona State, it was clear that when his mechanics were on point, things looked good. When they weren’t, he looked really bad. Footwork was an issue, and he rarely played on time. He was more of a creator than someone who was going to consistently beat you from the pocket. Trinidad Chambliss was successful under Lane Kiffin and Charlie Weis Jr. not only because he thrived off structure, but because he could also carve up defenses from the pocket. Leavitt hasn’t been able to do so consistently. Kiffin tried to get Brendan Sorsby at quarterback, and he was connected to Demond Williams Jr. during Williams’ brief portal flirtation. LSU ultimately ended up with Leavitt. The thought was that Leavitt’s talent and Kiffin’s ability to get the most out of his QBs would produce some big-time results. So far, it’s been a dud. 2. Not taking coordinator changes into account enough Dante Moore, Marcel Reed and Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele were all in the top 15 of our preseason rankings after encouraging 2025 seasons. Moore (No. 2) led Oregon to the semifinals of the College Football Playoff and would’ve likely been a first-round pick had he not returned to school. Reed (No. 13) struggled to end the season, but he did take Texas A&M to the CFP for the first time. Sagapolutele (No. 14), meanwhile, demonstrated immense potential as a true freshman for Cal last year. All three entered this season with new play callers. Moore was inconsistent under new offensive coordinator Drew Mehringer and seemed to regress before suffering a concussion against USC in late September. Mehringer was fired in October. Reed, too, has regressed under new coordinator Holmon Wiggins, who replaced Collin Klein, now the head coach at Kansas State. After throwing 25 touchdown passes and 12 interceptions last year, Reed has thrown eight TD passes and nine interceptions in 2026. His completion percentage is significantly lower (62.1 to 55.7), and his yardage is down as well. He and Texas A&M can’t run it back next season. Tosh Lupoi took over as Cal’s head coach this offseason and retained Sagapolutele to serve as the centerpiece of the program. Lupoi hired Jordan Somerville, who was an assistant QB coach with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, as his OC despite the fact that Somerville had never called plays. Sagapolutele hasn’t played well, but the offense was a complete mess, and Somerville was demoted in the first half of the season. Now there’s serious doubt about Sagapolutele’s future at Cal. Next season, we will take a deeper look at QBs who will have new play callers. Winners and Losers: Bachelor U and Airplanes Manny Navarro and Jeshua Kidd 3. Should’ve placed more faith in Keelon Russell’s talent Our rankings were published in mid-July, but most of the work was done in the weeks before. At the time, Russell was competing with Austin Mack for the QB1 role at Alabama. We projected Russell to win the job but ranked him 33rd, mainly because he didn’t get a lot of snaps last season and was unproven. Russell was a five-star prospect, so he clearly had talent, but just because a player was an elite recruit doesn’t mean he should be ranked highly once he becomes the starter. Look at Michigan’s Bryce Underwood and Tennessee’s Faizon Brandon as examples of how that could go wrong. But Russell’s talent, combined with Kalen DeBoer and coordinator Ryan Grubb’s ability to get a lot out of their QBs, should’ve been given more credence. Russell is one of the most promising QBs in the country and has Alabama in a great position to return to the CFP. 4. Too low on Maddux Madsen Heading into 2025, Madsen was our highest-ranked Group of 6 QB, but he didn’t really take a step forward and was banged up in 2025. This year, he was ranked No. 7 among G6 signal callers and No. 61 overall. That’s too low. It helps to have one of the best running games in the country and a playmaking wideout like Rasean Jones, but Madsen has made noticeable progress for the Boise State Broncos, who are the front-runners to grab the G6 Playoff spot. 5. Not enough skepticism with John Mateer Oklahoma ran back the same QB, offensive line and play caller that struggled last year and expected something different, which should’ve raised more questions in the preseason. The thought was that a healthy Mateer (No. 16) and a slew of tight ends would improve things. That hasn’t happened. The results have been better since the program parted ways with coordinator Ben Arbuckle and installed Jason Witten as the play caller, but it was too late to save the season for Mateer and the Sooners. 6. Overlooking Demond Williams’ situation at Washington Williams checked in at No. 20 in our rankings and has not taken the step forward many expected this season. The signs were there. The chemistry was always going to be awkward after he intended to transfer and returned only when it became clear it was going to be expensive to bolt. Not to mention, Washington lost high-end receiver Denzel Boston and standout running back Jonah Coleman to the NFL. Add injuries to skill players and a mediocre offensive line, and it makes sense that Williams hasn’t found overwhelming success in Washington’s offense. Injuries have affected Williams’ play this season, but the fact that there were questions a few weeks ago about whether he or Elijah Brown was the best option at quarterback illustrates how poorly things had gone. 7. Placed too much faith in potential NC State’s CJ Bailey (No. 17) and Maryland’s Malik Washington (No. 21) are certainly talented players who have had encouraging moments (or seasons in Bailey’s case) and who theoretically could be building blocks for their respective programs. But they’ve yet to put it all together, and both of their head coaches have already been fired, which puts their futures in doubt. Philip Rivers is taking over for Dave Doeren at NC State. Is Bailey his guy at quarterback? And does Bailey want to play for him? Maryland is replacing Mike Locksley. Washington was one of Locksley’s most significant signees, but a new coach changes the equation for Washington, who has been the face of the Terrapins’ program. Neither Bailey nor Washington has looked like a top-25 QB this season. 8. Slept on Weigman Conner Weigman has thrown for 2,552 yards (14th nationally) and 25 touchdowns (tied for sixth). He’s tossed just three interceptions, and he’s also rushed for 308 yards and seven scores. The former five-star who began his career at Texas A&M is having a very impressive season. He was ranked 28th in the preseason after throwing for 2,705 yards, rushing for 700 and accounting for 36 total touchdowns while helping Houston win 10 games in 2025. There are certainly more refined passers who we ranked ahead of Weigman, but most of them weren’t as productive as he was last season. And that probably should’ve counted for something. Now Weigman has taken his game to another level. 9. Underselling Michael Hawkins’ fit with Rich Rodriguez Hawkins ranked No. 72 due to his inconsistency as a passer when thrown into the fire as the starter at Oklahoma two years ago. Those struggles came against quality SEC defenses. We focused too much on what Hawkins isn’t than what he is — a great fit for Rodriguez’s running game. Hawkins has rushed for 960 yards (second-most among all QBs) and leads the nation (among all players) with 20 rushing TDs. He’s also passed for 2,128 yards, 13 touchdowns and three interceptions and has made West Virginia one of the most exciting offenses to watch in the entire country — Saturday’s ugly 37-14 loss at home to Kansas notwithstanding. 10. Not putting Gunner Stockton in the top 10 The knock on Stockton is that Georgia doesn’t necessarily ask him to drive the bus, but it’s not fair to call him a passenger either. He clearly likes the big moments and has played his best in the spotlight, whether against Alabama earlier this season, in the Sugar Bowl in the 2025 CFP or in a tough rivalry matchup on the road at Tennessee last year. Stockton is a gamer who will do whatever it takes to win, and he’s made progress this season with 2,109 passing yards, 239 rushing and 24 total touchdowns. We ranked him No. 11 coming into the season, which is still really good, but he’s played at a top-10 level, and Georgia is playing like the national title favorite.