JOHN DAVENPORT | Democrats must resist the temptation to misread what happened in the midterms
The Democrats won a remarkable victory in America’s midterm elections. However, if they believe voters have handed them a mandate for a sweeping liberal agenda, they could be making a very expensive mistake, one that will cost them dearly in the presidential election to come. The most important lesson from the midterm elections is not that America has suddenly moved to the left. It is that millions of Americans are frustrated, financially stretched and have lost patience with politicians who seem more interested in ideological battles than making everyday life affordable. Voters are worried about the price of groceries, housing, health care, petrol and electricity. They are worried about their wages and whether their children will enjoy a better standard of living than they do. This was neatly summed up by Democrat candidate Scott Colom in Mississippi. When his Republican opponent Cindy Hyde-Smith suggested voters facing the high cost of meat products should “change their protein”, Colom ran digital and TV ads saying they should instead “change their senator”. The voters who eviscerated GOP (Grand Old Party) candidates across the US did not necessarily vote for a grand progressive vision of America. They voted for candidates who they hope will make their lives easier. One can easily argue these voters did not vote for Democrats, they voted against President Donald Trump. The Republicans, under Trump, left the political centre almost completely unoccupied. Instead of concentrating on the economic concerns that helped return Trump to the White House in 2024, the administration became consumed by confrontation, controversy and increasingly bizarre political spectacle. The Democrats were smart enough to occupy that abandoned middle ground. Their success was built not simply on mobilising the progressive base, but on attracting independents, moderates and disillusioned Republican voters who were sick of Trumpian chaos, Trumpian price increases and what passes for foreign policy in the Trump White House. The voters who eviscerated GOP (Grand Old Party) candidates across the US did not necessarily vote for a grand progressive vision of America. They voted for candidates who they hope will make their lives easier. The danger is that the Democrats mistake an anti-Republican vote for an enthusiastic endorsement of every policy favoured by their progressive wing. Politicians are deeply prone to mistakenly thinking they can convince voters of their own political argument. That if they phrase their arguments right, they can change the ways voters think. This is almost always a mistake. An interesting indicator that US voters have not changed hugely is to compare the Senate campaigns in Michigan and Texas. Both the winning Democrat candidates were likable, charismatic men of about the same age, who said about the same things. One was named Abdul El-Sayed and the other was named James Talarico. While there were many other factors at play, Michigan should have been an easier win for the Democrats, but purely because of his ethnicity El-Sayed seemed to struggle more to get over the finish line in Michigan than Talarico did in Texas, the reddest of red states. Michigan voters struggled with the idea of voting for a man whose name was Adbul and not James. Competing factions within the Democrat multiverse will be claiming the election vindicates their particular political philosophy. However, for voters these issues are unlikely to be what resonated. For most Americans, politics is considerably less complicated than politicians think. Can I afford my mortgage? Will my healthcare bills come down? Can I put food on the table without worrying about the cost? These are the questions Democrats must answer. There will undoubtedly be pressure to use their newfound congressional power to pursue Trump, Jared Kushner, Pete Hegseth and other administration figures through endless investigations, hearings and legal battles. Legitimate oversight vs political retribution Where there is credible evidence of wrongdoing, accountability matters. Nobody should be above the law, no matter who their father is, or how magnificent their hair. However, there is a difference between legitimate oversight and allowing political retribution to become the defining purpose of a congressional majority. Americans did not elect Democrats simply to spend the next two years fighting yesterday’s battles and settle old scores. They elected them to improve tomorrow. That means prioritising economic growth, affordable housing, healthcare costs, wages and practical measures that put money back into ordinary Americans’ pockets. It also means being prepared to compromise, work across party lines and reject the temptation to turn every disagreement into an ideological confrontation. The political centre is not an absence of conviction. It is where durable electoral coalitions are built. It is where power lies. If Democrats want to win the presidency in 2028, they must demonstrate they can do more than oppose Trump. They must show they understand the everyday economic anxieties of ordinary Americans and can deliver tangible improvements. The Democrats have been given a second chance by Trump, who has trashed the Republican brand through years of ill-considered war, blatant corruption and Maga-flavoured madness. Democrats have a chance to prove they are a party that can govern from the middle, a chance to build a majority that could dominate the political landscape for years to come. However, if they mistakenly read these election results as a ringing endorsement of left-wing values that many Democrats hold dear, they will find out America has not changed nearly as much they think. • Davenport is CCO of Mediology. He is also a part-time psychology student, ungifted runner and occasional war correspondent. Business Day