India's Banking Model Offers Lessons For Latin America: Report
India’s experience with fiscal discipline, banking supervision and deposit protection could offer valuable lessons to Latin American countries, according to an India Narrative article. The report examines Paraguay’s fiscal challenges and Ueno Bank crisis alongside India’s experiences with Yes Bank and PMC Bank. Key Highlights India’s fiscal and banking reforms could provide lessons for Latin American economies. Paraguay’s Ueno Bank crisis highlights the importance of effective banking supervision. India’s Yes Bank and PMC Bank failures exposed weaknesses in risk monitoring and regulatory oversight. Paraguay’s deposit guarantee mechanism enabled provisional payments to 93% of insured depositors within five days. India’s Fiscal and Banking Model Offers Lessons for Latin America New Delhi, Nov 17: India’s experience in fiscal discipline, banking regulation and deposit protection could help Latin American countries strengthen their financial systems, according to an article published in India Narrative. The article examines Paraguay’s recent fiscal challenges and the crisis involving its largest digital bank, Ueno Bank, drawing comparisons with India’s experiences involving Yes Bank and Punjab and Maharashtra Co-operative (PMC) Bank . It argues that India’s experience offers lessons on the importance of maintaining fiscal rules, strengthening banking supervision and ensuring timely protection for depositors when financial institutions fail. Paraguay’s Fiscal Rules and India’s FRBM Experience Paraguay introduced its Fiscal Responsibility Law in 2013, seeking to keep the central government deficit within 1.5% of GDP . Its central bank, the Central Bank of Paraguay (BCP), follows an inflation-targeting framework with a target of 3.5%, with a tolerance band of two percentage points on either side. The framework is comparable to India’s inflation-targeting system, introduced in 2016, under which the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) aims to maintain inflation at 4%, with a tolerance band of plus or minus 2 percentage points . The article notes that Paraguay achieved investment-grade ratings from Moody’s in July 2024 and S&P in December 2025. However, successive governments reportedly breached or suspended the fiscal deficit ceiling in several years after 2019. The country’s fiscal position has also come under pressure from outstanding payments to drug suppliers and road contractors. The article cites estimates that Paraguay’s fiscal deficit could reach 3.2% in 2026 and 3.9% in the following year, with the deficit ceiling deferred to 2028. India’s own experience with the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act, introduced in 2003 , offers a parallel. Repeated postponements of fiscal targets led the N.K. Singh Committee to recommend a debt-based fiscal anchor in 2017. The article also refers to an IMF review that recommended Paraguay adopt a debt anchor and recognise expenditure based on delivery rather than merely on payments. Ueno Bank Crisis Highlights Banking Supervision Risks The Ueno Bank episode raises questions about banking supervision and the monitoring of financial institutions. According to the article, Ueno’s loans increased by around 30% during the first half of the year , while its deposits grew by only 10%. It also points to a potential conflict of interest arising from the appointment of the bank’s former head, Carlos Carvallo, as head of the Central Bank of Paraguay. The article compares this with India’s Yes Bank and PMC Bank failures. Yes Bank had reported apparently healthy capital ratios despite substantial exposure to stressed corporate borrowers. PMC Bank, meanwhile, concealed its exposure to real estate firm HDIL through thousands of dummy accounts. These cases highlighted the importance of timely regulatory intervention, independent supervision and transparency in banks’ financial disclosures. The article argues that safeguards are also needed to address conflicts of interest when individuals move between banking institutions, ownership roles and regulatory positions. Paraguay’s Deposit Guarantee System Offers a Model The article identifies Paraguay’s deposit guarantee framework as an important example for other countries. Under its Deposit Guarantee Law, introduced in 2003, deposits are protected up to 75 monthly minimum wages per depositor , equivalent to approximately $28,000, according to the article. Following the Ueno Bank crisis, the guarantee fund reportedly made provisional payments to 93% of 1.87 million insured depositors within five days , amounting to approximately $340 million. The article contrasts this with the experience of PMC Bank depositors in India, who faced a much longer wait for access to their insured deposits. India subsequently increased the deposit insurance cover provided by the Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC) to ₹5 lakh in 2020 . Amendments to the DICGC Act in 2021 also introduced a 90-day framework for payment of insured deposits in specified circumstances. Key Lessons for Latin American Countries The article suggests that Latin American governments can draw on both Paraguay’s deposit protection experience and India’s regulatory and fiscal reforms. It identifies three important elements: a legally defined fiscal deficit ceiling, an inflation-targeting central bank with operational independence, and a deposit guarantee system capable of making payments quickly when a bank fails. It also recommends strengthening fiscal rules through a debt anchor and accrual-based accounting to prevent unpaid liabilities from remaining hidden. For banking regulation, the article calls for a cooling-off period and strict conflict-of-interest restrictions for individuals moving between bank ownership, management and supervisory positions. The central argument is that countries can learn from the financial crises and regulatory reforms of others rather than bear the full economic and social cost of similar failures themselves. Paraguay’s fiscal challenges and Ueno Bank crisis, viewed alongside India’s experiences with Yes Bank and PMC Bank, underline the importance of credible fiscal rules, independent banking supervision and effective deposit insurance. The article argues that combining these safeguards could help Latin American countries strengthen financial stability and reduce the cost of future banking crises.