How Labour put Britain on course for worst Neets crisis on record

“You can choose to live in a country that believes in and backs its young people, the future of our country,” Sir Keir Starmer said in June 2024 as he unveiled Labour’s general election manifesto. “We can guarantee, for every young person, a job placement or apprenticeship when they are out of work.” Yet two years on, Labour is on course to preside over the worst youth worklessness crisis on record as its own policies make it harder for young people to find work . Some 1.27 million under-25s are forecast to be not in employment, education or training (Neet) by the start of the next decade, up from 981,000 today, according to Alan Milburn’s independent review of the crisis. In his 267-page report, published on Tuesday, Milburn says that surging levels of worklessness have been driven by ill-health, changes in the job market and Britain’s welfare system. However, the former Labour minister makes clear that the Government’s own policies have also played a key role in fuelling the crisis. Opportunities for young Britons have disappeared as Labour has pushed up the cost and risk of hiring them. Inflation-busting increases in youth minimum wage and changes to National Insurance that disproportionately hit under-25s have made it harder for people to gain a foothold on the career ladder. Labour’s Employment Rights Act, meant to deliver secure work for all, in fact risks making the problem worse, Milburn warns. In a damning verdict on Labour’s recent record, Milburn, who was health secretary under Sir Tony Blair, is calling for the Government to effectively reverse recent changes to National Insurance for under-25s and warns ministers against continuing to raise minimum wage. Labour must also rebuild trust with employers and should consider tempering the workers’ rights overhaul, he says. “Too often employers have been treated as if they were the problem rather than a central part of the solution,” Milburn warns. His findings are of little surprise to business leaders who have repeatedly warned that successive large increases to the youth rate of minimum wage, which began under the Conservatives and were continued by Labour, have made it unattractive to hire younger workers. In the past five years, the cost of employing someone aged 18 to 20 on the minimum wage has jumped by 65pc, the Milburn report highlights. The cost of employment has also risen after Rachel Reeves, the former chancellor, increased the rate of employers’ National Insurance contributions (NICs) from 13.8pc to 15pc in April 2025, as well as lowering the threshold that companies begin to pay the levy from £9,100 to £5,000. Many companies have been forced to reduce hiring, cut roles or offer staff fewer shifts in response. Often, it is young people who are at the sharp end. Milburn wrote: “An 18-year-old trying to enter the labour market for the first time is not in the same position as a 38-year-old with 20 years of experience. “If the cost to the employer is almost identical, too often the young person will lose out.” He warned that government policy should not make hiring young people “unnecessarily expensive”. In an attempt to tackle the problem, Milburn is calling for the Government to gradually increase the threshold that companies begin to pay National Insurance on young people’s wages. He wants the threshold for a young person aged 21 to 24 to rise from £5,000 to £10,000. This would not only reverse the effects of Reeves’s National Insurance changes but go further. Allen Simpson, the chief executive of UKHospitality, says lowering NICs for employers was “the only thing that matters”. “Don’t d--k about on the NICs thing,” he says. “I am nervous it won’t happen and if it doesn’t the whole thing is a bust. For hospitality, the reason we’ve lost 100,000 jobs in the last two years is because the Government has massively raised costs. The solution to that is to reduce costs.” Helen Dickinson, the chief executive of the British Retail Consortium, is urging the Government to implement Milburn’s recommendations “without delay”. Between 2024 and 2026, the retail sector lost 120,000 roles as businesses across the industry struggled with a £6.5bn increase in employment costs. “Retail is uniquely placed with entry level jobs across the country but retailers need the confidence and capacity to create those jobs and give young people their first step on the career ladder,” Dickinson says. Labour’s overhaul of workers’ rights also risks making it harder for young people to get a start in the world of work, Milburn warns. The Employment Rights Act received Royal Assent in December last year. The reforms grant workers day-one rights to sick pay, guaranteed hours and also scrap a cap on unfair dismissal claims. Bosses have been calling for changes to the act, which they argue has put them off hiring young people. One chief executive says that day-one sick rights, for example, have made people nervous about hiring younger staff for weekend shifts. “Young people are more likely to take sick days on core business days like Saturdays and Sundays for obvious reasons – they’re more likely to be hungover,” they say. Milburn heard “a powerful argument” from employers that these regulations made it more difficult to offer flexible work, he says. As companies hold back on hiring, young people are fighting it out for a declining number of roles as Britain’s labour market flatlines . Under-25s told Milburn tales of applying to dozens, or even hundreds, of open positions without ever hearing back. Milburn is calling for the Government to subsidise wages to encourage employers to take on more Neets. The former health secretary also wants the Government to introduce a £1.1bn-a-year employer incentive package, which he said could support 170,000 extra job and apprenticeship opportunities. In a sign that Labour under Andy Burnham is already changing course, John Healey, the Chancellor, has already slowed the rate of increase in the youth minimum wage. He announced in the Budget last month that the youth rate will climb by 3.9pc in April, the same pace as the rate for those aged 21 and older. However, business leaders say Labour must recognise the scale of mistakes made to date and reverse the damaging policies they oversaw during the first two years in government if they stand any hope of fixing the youth worklessness crisis. “On National Insurance, what’s happened since Rachel Reeves’s 2024 Budget is an employment disaster,” Jim Bligh, an executive at the British Retail Consortium, says. “Government needs to realise that was a game-changing mistake in 2024 and go back on as much of that as it can afford to do.”