How high is the Panic Meter for the Cavs, Jazz and others after slow starts?
Is it time to panic? Probably not if you work in an NBA front office, regardless of how dire things may seem for your franchise. It’s an 82-game season, shooting variance can make short-term results look a lot worse than they really are, and health has been a factor in several teams’ slow starts. It’s rare to see a team’s execs start smashing the panic button in mid-November; they’ll have plenty of time for that later. But for fans? That might be a different story. For instance, it’s hard to make your team’s case for eventual world domination when you have a double-digit negative scoring margin at the midpoint of November, something five teams could claim as of Sunday. In addition, new draft-lottery rules were supposed to make the standings look more balanced, but we haven’t really seen that so far. Subjectively, at least eight of the league’s 30 teams have looked just phenomenally hold-your-nose bad in the early going; the other 22 will presumably compete for the 20 postseason spots. Of course, some teams have more ambitious goals than receiving a gold star with “postseason participant” on it to commemorate a one-and-done Play-In Tournament excursion. I count six teams just in the Eastern Conference that went some level of “all in” on this season by giving up considerable future draft capital to bolster their present roster. Of those, only one, the Philadelphia 76ers, would likely call themselves happy with their start. Does tanking actually work? Here's what history shows. Zach Harper So, which teams’ fans should be panicking? Let’s measure things objectively. I’ve brought along my helpful analytical tool, the Panic Meter, to help analyze the situation. This carefully calibrated, scientific metric goes from one to five siren emojis based on a team’s current record, underlying stats and general vibes. It’s like a PER for fans’ emotional state. Timing-wise, I like to break out this tool after each team has played at least a dozen games. Voila ! The league’s biggest schedule laggard, the Denver Nuggets, finally played their 12th game on Monday. Of the league’s 30 teams, I have six that have generated enough concern thus far that MUST PANIC NOW is at least a credible potential response. Here they are, in no particular order. Cleveland Cavaliers: 🚨 🚨 🚨 There’s been a best-of-times, worst-of-times feel to the Cavs’ start, one that began with a déjà vu 29-point choke job in the opener against Philly and progressed unevenly since. On one hand, Cleveland probably couldn’t be happier with its recent moves around the margins. The much-bigger version of Mario Hezonja that returned to the NBA from Europe has locked down a rotation spot and had his contract guaranteed for the season. And the Cavs’ last two second-round picks (2025 49th pick Tyrese Proctor and 2026 34th pick Meleek Thomas) look like long-term keepers, if not the backcourt of the future. Proctor, who is shooting 45.5 percent from 3, had a triple-double Saturday against the Dallas Mavericks and scored 22 points on nine shots Friday against the Miami Heat, including a spectacular one-handed alley-oop dunk in transition. The 20-year-old Thomas, meanwhile, was supposed to be in the G League this season but instead is the Cavs’ fourth-leading scorer at 13.3 per game. Alas, the starting five has been phenomenally underwhelming, and unfortunately, that group is much more crucial to the Cavs’ immediate contention hopes. In particular, questions persist about 37-year-old James Harden’s ability to continue playing at a high level after his uneven start. On one glaring possession as the game was going off the rails Friday in Miami, Harden held the ball while burning 13 seconds of a 14-second reset shot clock, created zero inches of space with a series of dribbles against Davion Mitchell and then flailed into a contested 3 so far off target that it landed harmlessly on the leaf on the Robin Hood logo in Miami’s baseline — a difficult feat from the right wing. It’s not just Harden, though. The key free-agent pickup (small forward Peyton Watson) has yet to click with this group, posting just a 9.5 PER on 45.3 percent true shooting and not providing the hoped-for boost as a wing stopper. The Cavs, in fact, entered Monday 20th in defense despite mostly having their best players available. That stat also points a harsh light on star big man (and theoretical defensive linchpin) Evan Mobley, who has been fine thus far but hasn’t stood out the way a Cavs fan might have hoped and is now sidelined with a toe injury. All of this has led to widespread speculation about Kenny Atkinson’s future. Remember, when a team is capped out and has used all its draft assets, the only thing left is to change the coach. Cleveland saw firsthand last spring how that worked out for the New York Knicks. Yet, plugged-in league sources, speaking on the condition of anonymity to discuss team strategy, told The Athletic that a coaching change was unlikely unless things went badly off the rails, for one simple reason: There’s nobody on hand to promote. Atkinson has one of the league’s least-experienced staffs right now, so the fire-the-coach-and-promote-his-top-assistant routine doesn’t seem like a viable route. “Jordan Ott would have been the guy,” as one source put it, but the Phoenix Suns hired the former Cavs assistant two summers ago. As a result, any moves on Cleveland’s sideline would seem to be waiting for the offseason. Miami Heat: 🚨 🚨 My trip to South Florida this past weekend coincided with Friday’s Panic Bowl showdown between the Heat and Cleveland, but Miami — winners of five straight — is likely feeling better about itself following impressive back-to-back weekend wins over the Cavaliers and Detroit Pistons and then a 128-110 victory against the Houston Rockets on Monday. Nonetheless, I’m not sure the coast is entirely clear. Miami made its move for Giannis Antetokounmpo to move into the East penthouse, and last I checked, the Heat had a neutral scoring margin after 14 games — even with the star frontcourt combo of Antetokounmpo and Bam Adebayo playing all 14 of them. For a team almost completely stripped of assets and hard-capped at the first-apron payroll threshold , this feels problematic. The issue hasn’t been the two stars, but everyone else. Aside from a nice pop from Mitchell at point guard, Miami’s role players haven’t delivered. The Heat are starting the eminently cookable Klay Thompson to get enough shooting on the floor, but partly as a result of that trade-off, they are 22nd in defense. Some of that is because they’ve been hit by the deck on opponent 3-point luck — Heat opponents are at 38.8 percent from 3 — but Miami is also 23rd in 2-point defense. The offense has been pretty meh, too. Offsetting the team’s two stars, the wings have been pretty brutal. Andrew Wiggins was replaced in the starting lineup after nine games, free-agent pickup Tim Hardaway Jr. is shooting 25.9 percent and Simone Fontecchio has hardly seen the floor. (Can we have a conversation about that Duncan Robinson trade?) Up front, Bobby Portis and Nikola Jović combine to make $31 million this season; it would help if at least one of them looked like a rotation player. Miami’s recent play will calm nerves, as well as Erik Spoelstra’s lengthy history of pulling rabbits out of hats, but an upcoming Philly-New York-Cleveland trip will further load-test the idea that this version of the Heat can hang with the East’s elite. Dejounte Murray wants out of New Orleans. (Kelley L. Cox / Imagn Images) New Orleans Pelicans: 🚨 🚨 🚨 🚨 🚨 Pelicans players should all share the Twyman-Stokes Teammate of the Year Award. They’ve gone above and beyond to prove that Dejounte Murray isn’t the main problem. After an early four-game win streak generated some optimism, the last week has been a jarring reality check. New Orleans gave up at least 138 points in four straight games and had lost six straight entering Monday, seemingly openly mailing it in during at least a couple of this past week’s losses. Two of its five wins this season have come against Utah and Sacramento (more on them later), and the Pels are the only team to have lost to the Jazz. A visit from the Steph Curry-less Golden State Warriors on Monday provided a welcome salve to end the losing streak , but it may be a brief respite with Detroit, Oklahoma City and San Antonio up next. New Orleans brought in head coach Jamahl Mosley to help shore up the defense, but the Pels are the proud owners of the league’s worst defensive efficiency mark. Interior defense is a distinctly glaring issue. We talk a lot about rim protection, but this team might need a new stat called “rim enabling” — let’s just say the tag team of Karlo Matković and Derik Queen hasn’t been a major deterrent in the paint. The Pels are trying to stay competitive while developing 2025 lottery picks Jeremiah Fears and Queen, but even a team with less glaringly awful vibes than this one would find that a tough path to navigate. Each has had moments of brilliance, but both have made serial mistakes — especially on defense — that have been tough for a squad with such limited interior defense to overcome. It doesn’t help that Jordan Poole is soaking up $30 million on the bench and that key free-agent pickup Bennedict Mathurin has looked unplayable in his increasingly brief cameos. New Orleans has been this bad even with Zion Williamson playing in 14 of its 15 games and with a five-game ding to Trey Murphy III as the only significant injury. So, if you think things couldn’t get worse, well, actually ... What now? Murray has asked for a trade , and the Pels will presumably try to parlay his $32 million cap slot into a productive rotation player, especially a center, but the trade market usually doesn’t heat up until much later in the winter. In the meantime, it could be a long, depressing wait for Mardi Gras in the Big Easy. Orlando Magic: 🚨 🚨 🚨 What is this team, exactly? Theoretically built to win now around an expensive four-man core group, the Magic — now riding a four-game win streak after beating the Boston Celtics on Monday — entered the week with a strongly negative net rating (minus-4.5 points per 100 possessions) despite a soft early schedule. Theoretically built around defense, the Magic were 15th on that end entering the week. About the only constant is the offense: Orlando, as of Monday, ranked 26th in offense, tracking for a 15th consecutive season of finishing in the bottom half of the league on this end. The Curse of Dwight continues. Orlando brought in a new coach, Sean Sweeney, to try to shake its offensive doldrums, and at least one thing has changed: The Magic actually shoot 3s now. They have gone from 24th to sixth in 3-point frequency this season; alas, getting those shots to go in has proven more challenging. Orlando’s 33.7 percent mark ranks 23rd in the league; you can almost hear defenses yelling “He Wit Us!” as Franz Wagner (25.8 percent) or Jamal Cain (28.2 percent) tee one up. The reason this situation gets three alarms and not five is the injuries. Paolo Banchero and Jalen Suggs have missed considerable time, combining for just six games and continuing the maddening multiyear trend where Banchero and Wagner can never be healthy at the same time. More worrying, perhaps, is how unready the replacements have been. The Magic have tried to hide 2025 first-rounder Jase Richardson in the starting lineup, but he’s been exposed as utterly unthreatening on offense, a non-creator who also hasn’t shot well. (However, one fun sidebar has been watching point guards try to post up the tiny Richardson early in games and get utterly stonewalled. He’s tougher than you think.) Cain, Jevon Carter and Nikola Vučević have all struggled. Limited two-way Alex Morales makes frequent cameos for reasons that aren’t entirely clear. Goga Bitadze, hugely effective in a bench role last season, has largely been out of the mix. Already down two starters, the Magic have also been hurt by a sluggish start from Desmond Bane, who cost them four first-rounders to acquire in the summer of 2025. The silver lining is that two young reserves who normally have more limited roles, Anthony Black and Tristan da Silva, have proven their mettle with more playing time. In Black’s case, it may be a pyrrhic victory: The Magic didn’t extend his contract before the season and seemingly have few pathways to keeping him via restricted free agency next summer without trading one of their other expensive core pieces. Utah Jazz: 🚨 🚨 🚨 🚨 They tanked away half a decade for this ? The Jazz spent the last four seasons blatantly gaming their record to keep protected draft picks and set themselves up for a run at the playoffs this season, then started the campaign with a worse record than in any of the tanking seasons. Is that bad? It sounds bad. Ace Bailey and the Jazz have lost 12 in a row. (Rob Gray / Imagn Images) Utah’s 12th straight loss on Sunday was at least a competitive one against the mighty San Antonio Spurs. The Jazz have the obvious excuse that the two expected frontcourt linchpins, Lauri Markkanen and Jaren Jackson Jr., are injured and have combined for only 12 appearances so far. Nonetheless, the Jazz were finally supposed to be a decent team, and the start has been indecent. Jackson and Markkanen were unimpressive even when healthy, and their absences have exposed a weak forward rotation where Josh Okogie (PER 7.3, 48.5 percent true shooting), Josh Green (PER 4.8, 46.2 percent) and Svi Mykhailiuk (PER 4.5, 39 percent) have been varying neon hues of yuck. At center, meanwhile, the decision to trade Walker Kessler and the unavailability of Jusuf Nurkić have left a glaring weakness. The Jazz have started free-agent pickup Jaxson Hayes, but he seems a complete misfit with how they want to play (instead of running elbow actions with him, just punt the ball into the stands next time). It’s perhaps telling that Sunday’s more competitive showing came with Hayes out and reclamation project Mo Bamba pick-and-popping away. If there’s a kernel of good news, it’s in the play of Utah’s last two lottery picks. Rookie Darryn Peterson is becoming more comfortable by the day ripping 3s off the dribble, and the passing is starting to get interesting, while Ace Bailey has been more uneven on the offensive end but makes an exclamation-point-worthy defensive play nearly every night. Nonetheless, 2026-27 was thought to be the light at the end of the tunnel, and it’s turned out to be an oncoming train. Already, the Jazz are hopelessly behind in the chase for a postseason spot in the uber-competitive West. Utah’s 2027 first-round pick is already owed to Memphis from the Jackson trade; about the only silver lining is that, thanks to the last two tank jobs and the new lottery rules, it can’t fall in the top five. Sacramento Kings: 🚨 🚨 🚨 For any other team, this would be a five-alarm situation. But Kings fans? They’re used to this. Sure, they’re 1-12 and have lost all eight home games, but that’s not even the worst start in franchise history ... yet. (They’ll tie it if they falter Wednesday against Phoenix. Don’t worry, though; I’m sure the Lakers-Celtics-Spurs stretch that follows will go well.) Outscored by 13.8 points per game, the Kings have been so bad that even moving up to the league’s 27th-worst record — and thus avoiding the relegation zone that would damage their odds of winning the draft lottery — feels like a long shot. When “If only Ben Simmons hadn’t been hurt!” is a serious lament, you know the squad is in rough shape. The roster isn’t particularly young and makes no sense as a unit, nor in how it was built. (The De’Andre Hunter trade? The move to sign Dennis Schröder and then unload him? Trading for Dario Šarić? Yikes!) The Kings have steadfastly stood by perhaps the league’s least-qualified coach, used a first-round pick on a 24-year-old with a 0.7 PER (Alex Karaban) and might have less defensive talent than any other squad in the league. Sacramento, at least, knows who will have the keys to the offense going forward. Rookie Darius Acuff Jr. has been a scoring machine with deep shooting range and great elevation on his pull-up, and there is clear promise that he could become a Damian Lillard-esque offensive engine. Other small bright spots appear if you squint hard enough. Dylan Cardwell plays his butt off, second-rounder Emanuel Sharp’s effort is commendable and Precious Achiuwa was a heck of a scrap-heap find. Big picture, though, it’s pretty hard on the eyes. Aside from watching Acuff, the only things left on this season’s to-do list are winning nine more games to avoid the worst record in history, and getting anything — literally, anything — for contract mistakes such as Domantas Sabonis, Zach LaVine, Hunter and Malik Monk.