Harvard Study Finds Locked Phone Pouches Produce Modest Academic Gains: how 7 outlets framed it

Modest gains, big debate A large-scale study published Tuesday found strict cellphone restrictions that require students to put phones in locked pouches for the entire school day produce “modest” improvements in academic growth compared with students in similar schools without those restrictions. Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research led the analysis of test scores of 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools nationally, and the study estimated the academic gains were equivalent to about an additional week or two of learning over a school year. The study’s authors said the gains were not a panacea, with Harvard professor Thomas Kane saying, “Our answer is yes, phone bans do have a positive effect on growth. But it’s not a panacea,” while the study itself said storing students' phones is “a cost-effective way to add 1-2 weeks of instruction each year.” A different study published in May concluded strict school phone bans had “close to zero” effect on test scores, and it compared schools with bans with tens of thousands of other schools. Stanford education economist Thomas Dee said the early results are “largely disappointing” and raised unresolved questions, while also saying he was “not comfortable making that extrapolation from estimates that are small, sensitive and based on just a few years of phone bans.” Locked pouches and costs Chalkbeat said strict cell phone bans that require students to put their phones in locked pouches can increase test scores a little bit, about the equivalent of students spending one or two extra weeks in school every year, according to researchers at Harvard University and Dartmouth College. Tom Kane told Chalkbeat that “A strict cell phone ban is a low-cost way to add one to two weeks of instruction per year,” and he added that it is “certainly a cheaper way than paying teacher salaries for an extra one to two weeks.” The NPR report described the study as the first nationwide analysis of student-level test scores in math and reading both before and after schools enforced locked-pouch cellphone bans, and it said the gains appeared to continue year after year at least up to three years after adoption. NPR also quoted Brian Jacob, a co-author of the April study, saying, “Overall, we didn't find evidence of meaningful achievement gains,” while it described the April study as peer-reviewed and the more recent study as not peer-reviewed. The PR Newswire release said the study analyzed data from 3.3 million students attending 4,600 schools nationally during the 2021–22 through 2025–26 school years and said lockable pouches had an annual boost in achievement growth of 0.01 standard deviations, equivalent to 1–2 weeks of additional learning per year. What comes next The research debate is now tied to how schools implement bans, because Jean Twenge, a psychologist at San Diego State University and author of “10 Rules for Raising Kids in a High-Tech World,” said, “It happens pretty often that there’s a policy of no phones during the school day, bell-to-bell, and you go into the school and phones are everywhere.” “It happens pretty often that there’s a policy of no phones during the school day, bell-to-bell, and you go into the school and phones are everywhere.” ABC News Twenge also questioned whether schools simply shift students to other devices, asking, “Do they have laptops at school? Are they just doing social media on laptops instead?” The PR Newswire release said the study provides “first evidence on statewide bans during the 2025–26 school year,” and it also evaluated state-mandated bell-to-bell and instructional time bans in 22 states in 2025–26. The PR Newswire release reported that students in bell-to-bell ban states showed positive gains in reading (0.016 standard deviations) and students in states with instructional time bans showed gains in math (0.019 standard deviations), while researchers cautioned those findings might be confounded by pre-existing trends. The ABC News report said researchers sought to determine if the decline is being reversed now that schools have started taking phones away, and it quoted Thomas Kane saying learning loss was gradual over a decade and that gains would also be gradual. The coverage, compared whether locked-pouch bans are a sufficient policy solution Chalkbeat and NPR emphasise modest academic gains, while Medscape argues bell-to-bell bans are too simplistic. Original reports from 7 outlets ABC News Do school phone bans help students learn? So far, gains are 'modest' Chalkbeat Putting cell phones in Yondr pouches might yield an extra week of learning, a new study finds Medscape Cell Phones in School: The Baby or the Bath Water? NPR Do school cellphone bans work? New study says yes – but it's complicated Ocean State Media At this Rhode Island high school, fewer phones means more conversations PR Newswire U.S. 8th Graders Gradually Lost Equivalent of a Year's Learning Since 2013; New Research Implies In-School Cell Phone Use May Account for Half of the Historical Loss The New York Times New Evidence Shows School Phone Bans Are Gradually Improving Test Scores