‘Half measures will not do’: Milburn calls for wholesale reform as he publishes major youth unemployment report – live

From 1h ago 'Half measures will not do' - Milburn makes case for wholesale reform as he publishes his youth unemployment report Milburn is restating a case that he has been making in public for months now – that there is a moral case for tackling the Neet crisis. double quotation mark A lost generation is not a fact of life. It’s a choice. And I believe it’s the wrong one. Not just because it’s a fiscal crisis or an economic one, because it’s a moral crisis. We are failing as a nation to gift young people, the next generation, the opportunities they need to succeed. We forecast that within five years, Neet numbers will be well above 1 million and indeed will be an excess of 1.25 million. So the conclusion I’ve come to is that half measures will not do. The scale of the problem is just too big for that. We have reached a profound moment of choice for the country. It calls for a new approach to back the next generation, to make young people a top priority. Key events 52s ago McFadden says Jobs Guarantee for young people to be available after 12 months on universal credit, not 18 months 4m ago Burnham setting up new Youth Opportunities Unit reporting to No 10, McFadden tells MPs 11m ago McFadden says government also accepts Milburn's recommendation for personalised benefits system for young people 12m ago McFadden says government backs Milburn's recommendation for statutory Young People's Guarantee 20m ago Pat McFadden tells MPs cabinet has endorsed need for whole new settlement for young people 37m ago 'Let's see what happens next' - Milburn sounds open to taking government post to help implement his plans 41m ago Milburn says 'British promise' to young people, 'work hard and build a better life', is broken and must be restored 44m ago Milburn explains why he rejected plans that would cut costs more quickly 48m ago Milburn says relying on supply-side economics alone to tackle youth unemployment has been 'biggest fallacy' in policy for 50 years 1h ago What Milburn is proposing in his report 1h ago 'Half measures will not do' - Milburn makes case for wholesale reform as he publishes his youth unemployment report 1h ago What DWP says about how public spending has been skewed towards pensioners rather than young people 1h ago What DWP says about what Milburn plan would cost and achieve over 10 years 1h ago Annual costs and savings from Milburn plans by 2036/37 2h ago How Milburn plans could cut Neet rate 2h ago Milburn says his plan to get young people into work will save only £200m a year 2h ago DWP releases figures showing getting rid of two-child benefit cap has lifted 300,000 children out of poverty 2h ago What opposition parties are saying about Milburn's plan 3h ago Ed Miliband announces first sanctions on Israeli firms working in West Bank 3h ago Milburn says small firms should be paid £5,000 to hire Neets 3h ago Milburn says response from Labour MPs to his plans has been 'incredibly positive' so far 4h ago UK unemployment unexpectedly eases to 4.6%, as government prepares to release Milburn report 4h ago Alan Milburn says youth unemployment plan could cut welfare bill, but overall savings will take years McFadden says Jobs Guarantee for young people to be available after 12 months on universal credit, not 18 months McFadden said Milburn was recommending that the Jobs Guarantee should be available to young people after 12 months on universal credit, not 18 months. He said the government agreed. The Jobs Guarantee offers young people a fully-funded job for six months. McFadden said the government would “work with the devolved governments to ensure that the benefits of local delivery and personalised support are available for young people throughout the United Kingdom”. Burnham setting up new Youth Opportunities Unit reporting to No 10, McFadden tells MPs McFadden summed up what Milburn is proposing about changing benefits for young people. double quotation mark The report recommends a youth allowance which people will receive whilst they receive help from the Youth Opportunity Service, with extra support for care leavers and those outside the family home. It says young people whose disabilities or health conditions create significant enduring additional costs, including those with conditions that fluctuate, should continue to receive help with those costs and that support should not be put at risk if they start work. And because people should not always have to wait for a national assessment for short term help, it proposes a dedicated, locally held fund to help with one off costs or temporary cash support. And for those with the most severe and lifelong conditions where work is not a realistic prospect, Alan Milburn recommends a stronger safety net, providing dignity and security, and an end to unnecessary reassessments. McFadden defended focusing more on employment support than on cash benefits for some young people. double quotation mark The right priority should be earlier and more intensive spport with their health, education and employment to help them build a better future, to help change the situation that we have right now where a 20-year-old who signs on for long-term sickness benefits is more likely to mark their 30th birthday and still be on those benefits than to have had a steady job in any of the intervening ten years. And he said Andy Burnham today told cabinet he was setting up a new Youth Opportunities Unit, reporting directly to No 10, to deliver this. McFadden says government also accepts Milburn's recommendation for personalised benefits system for young people McFadden went on: double quotation mark [Milburn’s] second recommendation is for a more personalised system, which treats people as human beings, not as departmental clients, with employment, education, skills, health and weight of support brought together around the person and crucially, that this be delivered locally. The government also accepts this second recommendation. More local delivery with proper standards and accountability for outcomes. This is common in other countries with significantly lower rates of youth inactivity, because local leaders have the knowledge, the relationships and the networks to connect young people to the support and opportunities that make sense for them. Every eligible young person who falls out of education or work should have one place to turn, one trusted person responsible for helping them, and one plan bringing together the support they need. McFadden says government backs Milburn's recommendation for statutory Young People's Guarantee McFadden said one of Milburn’s key recommendations is for “a new opportunity and support guarantee backed by legislation, so that every young person who is not earning or learning has a credible route into education, training and apprenticeship, high quality work experience or a job.” He goes on: “And we support this recommendation.” Here is what the Milburn report says about the Young People’s Guarantee. double quotation mark One of this review’s central proposals is a new Young People’s Guarantee that is enshrined in law. It is not another temporary programme. It is a permanent new deal between young people and the state. At its heart are 2 promises. The Opportunity Guarantee is a statutory entitlement to a place in education, training or work for all young people aged 18 to 24. The Support Guarantee is an entitlement to the health, employment, functional and practical support needed to take that opportunity up and sustain it. The new Young People’s Guarantee proposed here extends opportunities and support to every 18 to 24 year-old who is NeeT and needs a route back into earning or learning, regardless of benefit status. The current policy is narrower than the problem. It does not fully extend to young people assessed as having health conditions or disabilities, who now make up a large and growing proportion of the NeeT population. In 2025, 44% of NeeT young people reported a work limiting health condition, up from 26% in 2015. It also starts from age 16 where serious risk of disengagement is already clear. McFadden said the government had already started introducing policies to improve opportunities for young people, such as the £2.5bn Youth Guarantee. But Milburn was right to call for a system that that is “more personalised, more devolved and focussed on participation”, he said. Pat McFadden tells MPs cabinet has endorsed need for whole new settlement for young people Alan Milburn is still speaking at his press conference, but the broadcasters are switching to the Commons, where Pat McFadden , the work and pensions secretary, is giving a statement about the report. McFadden says sometimes a report for government deals with an issue “so fundamental that it alters what we see as the contract between government and society”. He goes on: double quotation mark I believe this is one such report, because one million young people not in education, employment or training creates a human cost that no country should ask its young people to bear. It robs them of the thing that is most important to their lives – the prospect of a good future. Echoing Milburn (see 11.53am ), McFadden insists young people are not snowflakes. double quotation mark We reject that entirely. The fault does not lay with the young people themselves. They want to work. They want to learn. It is for us to make sure that they have a chance to do so. So our message to young people, the message from me, from the prime minister, from the whole cabinet, is that we value you, we believe in you, and we want you to have a future. He says Milburn spoke at cabinet this morning. He goes on: double quotation mark That is why when the cabinet met this morning to discuss the report, the prime minister and the whole cabinet endorsed the need for a whole new system for young people, one that puts work and opportunity at its heart, with earlier intervention, stronger support, more devolution and clear expectations to take part. OIIne that changes the question the state asks to a much deeper and more fundamental question. And that is: how do we help people live the fullest life? Q: [From Richard Partington from the Guardian] There have been suggestions this new approach to welfare could be extended to over-25s. What would your response to that be? Milburn says different age groups have different needs. He recalls unemployment in the 1980s, when he was active in the trade union movement. There were three million people unemployed. But it was cyclical, he says. double quotation mark Then the economy recovered and youth employment picked up. This is no longer cyclical. It’s structural. It’s young people not being in the labour market. They’re detached from the labour market. They’ve never had the chance to be unemployed because they’ve never been employed. And the numbers are getting worse. Q: Do you think regulation needs to be cut to help employers, as well as taxes? Milburn says it is sometimes hard to see what regulations could be cut to help employers. But he gives an example; he says a sole employer hiring a young person needs to take out insurance. double quotation mark If you’re an employer having to take about a special insurance scheme, that’s a hassle. But it’s also a cost, costing around £300. And that’s that’s something that we think should be ended. 'Let's see what happens next' - Milburn sounds open to taking government post to help implement his plans Milburn is now taking questions. Q: [From Ryan Sabey from the Sun] What is your advice to the PM about negotiating a youth mobility scheme with the EU? Will that help young people get a job? Milburn says young people in British communities must come first. There has been an over-dependence on migrant labour. But the fall in migration creates an opportunity, he says. Q: If you were offered a job to implement this, would you accept? Milburn replies: double quotation mark I’ve done my review. Let’s see what happens next. But obviously I’m not going to walk away from this. You know, I care about it. I’ve cared about it for countless years – I was going to say decades, but it probably is decades. So let’s see where that goes. Milburn says 'British promise' to young people, 'work hard and build a better life', is broken and must be restored Milburn says he is a member of a generation that has been lucky. double quotation mark I’ve been incredibly lucky in my life. I grew up on a council estate, and I had the fortune to end up serving in the cabinet. I’m part of a generation that has, by and large, done pretty well. We entered a labour market where the first rung of the career ladder was easier to reach. For many of us, housing was more affordable. We benefited from expanded educational opportunities. Like so many other people of my generation, I was the first in my family to go to university and we inherited a simple promise from our parents. But the promise on offer to young people in the past is now broken, he says. double quotation mark Work hard and you build a better life. That great British promise for this generation is being broken. Our job is to fix it. The response to the interim report we published in May has convinced me. There is a visceral mood for change in the country. Parents and grandparents feel it. Employers feel it. Politicians feel it too. They all know that the risk of a lost generation of young people is real. Being Neet used to be something that happened to other people’s children. Now, when a third of young people who are Neet have five good GCSEs, when 15% of them have a degree, parents are wondering whether it’s going to happen to their son or their daughter. Milburn explains why he rejected plans that would cut costs more quickly Milburn restates his view that, over time, his proposals will produce savings for the state. (See 9.04am and 11.36am .) He says he did consider trying to cut costs more quickly. double quotation mark I‘ve looked long and hard at whether more could be achieved earlier. It could, but only through crude benefit cuts without the accompanying support. I do not believe that it’s defensible morally, any more than I believe it will work fiscally. It would plunge more young people into destitution, and the costs would simply show up in another part of the state’s balance sheet in increased spending on housing or health or crime. So I believe the approach I advocate is both radical and, critically, it’s doable.