Don’t let college football’s billions distract you from the absurdity of coaching buyouts - The New York Times

To be a college football fan today is to feel nickel-and-dimed at every corner. Universities and athletic departments (and conferences, and networks, and also do not forget Dr Pepper) want your ticket money; they want your concessions cash; they want your NIL donations; they want it all. And they forever feel obliged to remind you they simply have no choice, that the only way they can compete at the highest level is if you give them all this money, to the point that if you don’t pony up, well, it’s not their fault if they’re losing: It might just be yours . Every penny counts. What can you do? It’s just what the sport is now! They have to spend this money! And then you read about the buyouts. I have a friend who is a cardiologist. He’s a very nice guy, but he also drives the most expensive car of anyone I know, wears a watch that’s bigger than my head and also, every time he texts me, seems to be in Aruba or Venice or the Caymans or some super fancy place I’ll never visit. I don’t know exactly how much money he makes, but I can make a pretty good guess based on a recent Doximity study that set the median cardiologist’s annual income at $604,635. Now, becoming a cardiologist is extremely difficult: You’ve got four years of undergrad, four years of medical school (which less than half the applicants get into ), three years of residency, three more years of a cardiovascular disease fellowship after that and, often, three more years of interventional cardiology and electrophysiology fellowships . That’s up to 17 years of (very expensive) schooling and training just to have the opportunity to do one of the most stressful, in-demand jobs in modern medicine. Cardiologists are the absolute top of their field, and they are paid accordingly. And ask anyone who has ever needed one: They’re worth it all. And my cardiologist friend, who I presume is vacationing somewhere in outer space right now, would have to work approximately 106 years to make as much money as Nebraska coach Matt Rhule would get for getting fired this very second. The money figures thrown around college football can sometimes be so absurd that they hardly register anymore, from billion-dollar television contracts to reported $7.5 million quarterback deals . But I don’t think it’s possible to ever be numb to how much money football coaches get paid after they are fired. USC loses third game of season, likely out of playoff discussion Justin Williams and Bryce Cohen We’ve all been fired, and it’s always painful, but it certainly is a little less painful when you’re Mike Norvell and Florida State pays you $50 million to leave . You have to really want to get rid of a guy if you’ll give him $50 million to get out of your face. (When I got laid off from my old dot-com startup, they didn’t even let me keep the pencils.) A disturbingly large percentage of college football conversations this time of year are about which coaches are going to be fired, and most of these are largely dictated by the size of these buyouts. USC’s Lincoln Riley has a buyout believed to be in the ballpark of $70 million. Clemson’s Dabo Swinney? $57 million. South Carolina’s Shane Beamer and Wisconsin’s Luke Fickell : both over $20 million. And, of course, there is Rhule. He has a 25-23 record in four seasons and got an extension after his name was connected to the Penn State vacancy a year ago. His buyout: $64 million . This isn’t how much money these coaches make in salary. It’s just what it requires them to be paid just so they will go away. It is difficult to overstate how bizarre this is. What’s maybe strangest about it is that an amount of money like that being given out to fire a coach early would seem to imply that a coach firing is an act of God, some out-of-nowhere, unforeseen calamity that’s so shocking it triggers some sort of rarely used emergency escape hatch, as opposed to ... something that happens constantly, all of the time, every season, to everybody. There are only six active Power 4 coaches who have had their current jobs longer than 10 years: Iowa’s Kirk Ferentz, Pittsburgh’s Pat Narduzzi, Georgia’s Kirby Smart, BYU’s Kalani Sitake, Minnesota’s P.J. Fleck and Swinney. Every other job has turned over in the past decade, because coaches are constantly getting fired. This is what sports are! The old baseball manager Leo Durocher once said, “If you don’t win, you’re going to be fired. If you do win, you’ve only put off the day you’re going to be fired.” But, in a profession that is strictly defined by its cyclical nature and constant turnover, coaches keep getting staggering amounts of money for doing the thing that, by the nature of the job, ends up happening to every coach. Why? The finances of the sport have arguably shifted away from spending so much of your budget on coaches, after all. You could maybe make the case that pouring your entire athletic budget into the top dog made sense when you were signing these big TV deals and only had to give the players a scholarship (and the occasional pickup truck under the table, if you could find a big enough table). But every dollar that goes to a coach now — whether he’s coaching or just watching his old team play without him — is a dollar you could pay for an actual player , one who runs around on the field and wears pads and touches the ball and everything. Professional sports act this way: The average baseball manager is paid roughly $2.5 million a year, which might not crack the top 200 highest-paid players. The NBA is similar; the average coach makes less than most of his players do. Of course, those players all have unions representing their interests; most of college football is trying to move in the opposite direction . Certainly, though: If you were a billionaire funding a football program , you’d much rather spend your money to bring in a new quarterback than to pay a coach to stay away from your program, no? The reason seems increasingly clear: Athletic directors have the memory of a goldfish. You may remember when LSU fired Brian Kelly, just one year ago , the (not always helpful) governor of Louisiana made a big deal out of mocking then-LSU athletic director Scott Woodward for giving Kelly a $53 million buyout. “I can tell you right now, Scott Woodward is not selecting the next coach,” Gov. Jeff Landry said. “Hell, I’ll let Donald Trump select it before I let him do it. The guy (Woodward) that’s here now that wrote (Kelly’s) contract cost Texas A&M 70-something million dollars. Right now, we’re on the hook for a $53 million liability. We are not doing that again.” You are never going to believe what happened next: LSU hired a coach and gave him a contract that, if it were to fire him after this season, would cost it $62 million . Now, LSU didn’t imagine firing Lane Kiffin after one season; no one ever imagines firing their coach; that’s why they give them the buyouts in the first place. And yet here we are, one year later, with everybody angry at Kiffin amid a disappointing season . But don’t worry: If he has another bad season in 2027, the buyout falls to ... $52 million. So the Tigers have that going for them. Another fun aspect of many (but not all — including Kiffin !) of these contracts: The requirement, when a buyout is paid, that a fired coach make a “good-faith effort” to find another coaching job to offset the buyout payment. This is exactly what is happening with Kelly, who interviewed for the Maryland job last week . Now, maybe Kelly is going to get that job and maybe he isn’t, but by virtue of the interview itself, he is making a good-faith effort. For what it’s worth, this is a part of being a football coach I think I would be excellent at: Bombing out an interview at a job I don’t actually want to make sure I get paid all the money I’m currently receiving for not working. “What’s that? You want to know what my play-calling strategy would be? My answer is that I would only play nine offensive players at a time, and I would have them all face the opposite direction of where we are trying to drive the ball. Oh, that’s not what you want? You mean I don’t get the job now? Well, darn it. Hey, you validate parking, right?” I know that athletic directors, and coaches, and definitely coaches’ agents, will say that this is simply a matter of negotiation, that they are maximizing what the market will bear, that this is merely how valuable coaches really are. And sure, if you’re Kirby Smart or Curt Cignetti, maybe. (Maybe.) But it sure looks to me like the most inefficient market imaginable — a bunch of savvy people taking advantage of the easiest marks on the planet. College football is a sport that is driven by emotion and run by people, whether they’re athletic directors, school presidents or billionaire boosters, who, when things aren’t going well, want to pound the table and stomp their feet and, dammit, just freaking fire somebody so they can feel like they’re actually doing something. Then the new coach comes in, the new savior, and they just give him whatever he wants ... just like they did the last guy. Remember that when your school is raising its ticket prices, or hectoring you about giving to the NIL collective, or charging you to watch its highlights : It is likely going to end up using that money to, in five years, pay a guy to chill on a beach. Nice work if you can get it. Sure beats heart surgery.