Does Your Grandma Want Politics Out of Superhero Stories?

It appears that the Gunn has jammed. Following the backlash surrounding Paramount’s purchase of Warner Bros. Discovery in October, the new combined company, Skydance, announced it would be “preserving iconic brands with independent creative leadership” and promoting work opportunities for creators. Though one might think this protected the jobs of current Warner Bros. employees, both James Gunn and Peter Safran were fired on Nov. 6 after four years in their influential roles as the chief executives of DC Studios. Skydance largely claims that they were fired for two key factors: a lack of earnings and their inability to capture the cultural zeitgeist. The first reason, profit, is an unfair comparison of a burgeoning DC Universe to a matured Marvel Cinematic Universe, with hits like Marvel’s Spiderman: Brand New Day (2026) releasing parallel to DC Studios’ box-office flop , Supergirl (2026). Though they aren’t bringing in billions, projects like Superman (2025) and Clayface (2026) have actually made the DCU a profit . Skydance’s second critique — the lack of influence on pop culture — refers to Lanterns (2026); while it broke HBO Max records with 19 million average viewers per episode, it didn’t stay topical for long after its finale. Still, Gunn and Safran were undeniably able to weave their way into the zeitgeist — considering how, after Superman ’s release, Iggy Pop’s “Punkrocker” boomed on social media and charted 19 years after its release. The former heads are being replaced with Marvel veteran Jeremy Latcham , who will take up the role of chief creative officer and president of this new iteration of DC Studios. Given the weak reasoning for firing the previous pair, there appears to be an ulterior motive to get Latcham in control. As an employee at Marvel Studios for 13 years, his experience might bring the new DCU to the same level of stardom — unlike Gunn, who was temporarily fired by the same studio in 2018. While this may be true, it was likely not the tipping point for Skydance. Latcham recently stated in an interview that his “guiding light” in producing Marvel movies was questioning “if [his] grandma would like that.” While it is not necessarily a bad idea to pander to a wide audience, Latcham’s language demonstrates an eagerness to generalize content for easy profit instead of staying true to fans and the comics being put to screen. This can easily strip away too much detail and complexity from the source material, making for a dull and generic product. Some audiences have already been experiencing fatigue with superhero movies, given their formulaic and predictable nature. Shifts like this can drive away viewers, as an intriguing plot is what best keeps their attention captured. Young people especially want to enjoy more thoughtful movies — a fact that would only hurt the broader consumption Latcham is desperate to raise. However, it’s not simply the sentiment of what Latcham said in this interview that is important; the fact that he spoke with the Christian Broadcasting Network is what is especially concerning. This is an organization notoriously aligned with far-right politics; its former head Pat Robertson has been a driving force of Christian nationalism in America, specifically its prevalence in the Republican Party over the past few decades. In accepting an interview with such a network, delivering rhetoric that movies must be safe and appealing to all, Jeremy Latcham’s words become dangerous. Whether it means he might simply strip political discussion from the DCU or actively push the studio toward the right, Latcham’s capacity to manipulate the vision and execution of creatives is harmful to the art of film and free speech as a whole. The DCU pre-Latcham has been anything but apolitical. Gunn’s The Suicide Squad (2021) was a blatant critique of American imperialism; Peacemaker (2022) portrayed issues of bigotry and the way racism has rooted itself into nationalism and America’s social systems; even Supergirl took a big swing and made its main villains the leaders of a galactic sex-trafficking network. Superman , Gunn’s biggest project in the DCU, contained a geopolitical conflict that portrayed an unintentionally yet absurdly accurate allegory to the ongoing conflicts in the Middle East and between Russia and Ukraine. But would Latcham’s grandmother enjoy that? Or would she want a watered down story of a bad guy doing bad things for bad reasons, devoid of any of the complexity surrounding these systemic issues? Would she want to know that, even in a fictional world with superheros, these unjust systems are foci of true societal harm? The move to replace Gunn and Safran with Latcham seems to be part of Skydance’s overarching shift toward supposed political neutrality, a masked push to conservatism. There have already been steps taken elsewhere by David Ellison, Skydance’s owner, to swing further right, ensuring the acquisition will be allowed by the FCC and give the new company as big a consumer base as possible. For example, Skydance pledged to remove DEI and bias from CBS, all while having Paramount pay President Trump $16 million to settle his legal dispute with 60 Minutes. By conceding to acts like this in the name of profit and removing activism from media, the potential of these stories is immensely undercut, especially when adapting a medium so fundamentally political; superheroes first became popular as a direct result of World War II. Removing politics from superhero stories is antithetical to their very purpose because they are ideology-based characters. They often work outside the bounds of the government, at times in direct opposition, to ensure the greater good for all people. They show that, despite bureaucracy, things can and will get better, not just because they have great power but because of the voice this power gives them. While Gunn and Safran may not have made the most startling profit in their time with the DCU, they told strong stories about topics worth discussing. We can only hope that Latcham’s grandmother cares about these kinds of issues, too, rather than just enjoying something that is all spectacle, no substance. Aarav Bavishi Aarav Bavishi is a member of the Class of 2029 in the Brooks School of Public Policy. He is a staff writer for the Arts & Culture department and can be reached at [email protected]. Read More