DoE defends bar on court challenges by losing coal auction bidders

November 17, 2026 | 9:03 pm By Sheldeen Joy Talavera, Reporter THE DEPARTMENT of Energy (DoE) said a provision in the coal auction rules that bars losing bidders from contesting results in court is intended to promote stability and reinforce the integrity of the bidding process. “That’s how it’s being done already in many of the bidding process of the government. And it gives also the process some form of stability and credibility,” Energy Secretary Sharon S. Garin said at a briefing on Tuesday. Ms. Garin’s comment came after Consunji-led Semirara Mining and Power Corp. (SMPC) questioned the DoE’s rules on the auction of coal operating contracts for development and production. SMPC claimed that the auction rules require bidders “to waive their legal and constitutional rights including going to court to question any part of the bidding process.” The company also slammed the DoE’s rule requiring incumbent mine operators to surrender their key assets, saying it’s “confiscatory.” “At a time when the country is the focus of the whole world, here comes the DoE issuing this ill-advised confiscatory and outright illegal provision apparently to keep us out of the bidding,” the company said. Last week, the DoE officially relaunched the coal bid round, offering three pre-determined areas, which are estimated to hold around 207 million metric tons of coal reserves. One of the areas at stake is the Semirara mine site in Antique, SMPC’s flagship asset, which the company has operated for nearly 50 years but failed to secure a renewal ahead of the current mining contract’s expiration in July 2027. Coal operating contracts are targeted to be awarded to the winning bidders by Jan. 13, 2027. Under the DoE’s notice of bidding, participation in the bid round means waiving the right to seek court orders that would stop or restrain the bidding process and the subsequent awarding and implementation of contracts. Ms. Garin said the same rule applies to public-private partnership projects, where bidders waive their right to seek court orders that would halt or restrain the bidding process and the implementation of awarded contracts. Amid concerns over the provision, the Energy chief said the department has received positive feedback from stakeholders during consultations and has been adjusting the bidding terms based on their recommendations. “We’ll reassess if there’s any problem that we encounter. But so far, everything’s been good,” she said. Globalinks Securities and Stocks, Inc. Head of Sales Trading Toby Allan C. Arce said the government should prevent frivolous legal challenges that could delay critical energy projects but cautioned against a blanket ban on losing bidders seeking judicial remedies. “There is an important distinction between preventing unsuccessful bidders from challenging legitimate outcomes simply because they lost and denying them the opportunity to contest genuine irregularities, procedural violations or possible abuses of discretion,” Mr. Arce said in a Viber message. He said investor confidence depends not only on the finality of bidding results but also on transparency, fairness and appropriate checks and balances. An overly restrictive waiver, he added, could discourage credible investors concerned about regulatory predictability and investment protection.