Democratic Senators Challenge CFTC’s Geofencing Policy
Nine Democratic senators are urging the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to reverse its position on prediction market geofencing. They argue that the agency's latest interpretation could undermine state and tribal gaming laws. In a November 16 letter to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, the lawmakers challenged the agency's November 5 guidance. They want prediction market exchanges to retain the ability to block customers in jurisdictions where courts have restricted their contracts. The senators also requested that the CFTC preserve records and communications concerning prediction markets. Their intervention adds congressional pressure to an ongoing dispute over federal oversight and state gambling enforcement. Democratic Senators Challenge CFTC's Geofencing Interpretation Senator Adam Schiff of California led the initiative , joined by eight other Democratic lawmakers. The group includes Senate Agriculture Committee Ranking Member Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota. The committee directly oversees the CFTC. The senators argue that the agency's position conflicts with existing court orders against prediction market operators. However, Selig maintains that designated contract markets (DCMs) must provide consistent nationwide access. "Derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale in order to achieve the purposes set out in the Commodity Exchange Act," Selig said. "Geographic access restrictions are inconsistent with those purposes and the Act's impartial access requirements." The CFTC's interpretation gave DCMs 30 days to remove domestic geographic restrictions that violate its impartial access requirements. Alternatively, exchanges must explain why compliance is not feasible. This gives affected operators until December 5 to comply or submit their explanations to the agency's Division of Market Oversight. However, the senators believe this approach could undermine judicial decisions involving sports-related event contracts. They specifically cited restrictions affecting Michigan, Nevada, Washington, and two California tribal territories. "Numerous courts have held that sports-related event contracts are not swaps and instead are indistinguishable from sports bets subject to state and tribal gaming laws... The courts have ordered platforms to cease offering various prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada, and Washington, and on the land of two California tribes, and imposed geofencing requirements. The Commission now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders during active litigation," the senators wrote. Senators Seek Preservation of CFTC Records Beyond the policy dispute, the lawmakers want the agency to preserve all prediction market-related records from January 1, 2025. Their request covers official and personal emails, text messages, encrypted communications, meeting notes, calendars, voicemails and social media activity. They also want the CFTC to suspend automatic deletion procedures. The senators requested written confirmation that the agency would preserve these materials. They gave Selig until November 23, 2026, to respond. Former CFTC senior trial attorney Braden Perry described the request as a potential warning sign. He noted that the letter could precede a broader investigation into the agency's handling of prediction markets. The preservation demand also references communication channels involved in previous CFTC enforcement actions. Between December 2021 and August 2023, the agency imposed more than $1 billion in penalties on 18 financial institutions. Those penalties addressed employees' use of unauthorized messaging channels. Perry believes the request could help lawmakers establish how the CFTC developed its latest policy. It could also provide grounds for further congressional scrutiny. CFTC's Legal Battles With States Add to Regulatory Dispute The senators' intervention comes as the CFTC actively challenges state efforts to restrict prediction markets. The agency has filed lawsuits against approximately a dozen states to defend its federal regulatory authority. Arkansas and Louisiana represent the latest targets. Last week, the CFTC filed separate federal lawsuits against both states. The Arkansas lawsuit challenges the state's efforts to halt event-contract trading and impose penalties on federally registered exchanges. Meanwhile, the Louisiana case followed a state court order restricting more than 30 companies connected to CFTC-regulated derivatives. The agency argues that the Commodity Exchange Act gives it exclusive jurisdiction over these federally regulated markets. Selig has repeatedly rejected state attempts to apply gambling restrictions to registered exchanges. These lawsuits demonstrate how aggressively the CFTC is defending its nationwide regulatory approach. They also deepen the conflict with state authorities that consider sports-related event contracts subject to gambling laws. Prediction Markets Face Uncertain Regulatory Future The disagreement highlights the growing conflict between federal derivatives regulation and state gambling enforcement. This distinction matters because prediction markets increasingly offer contracts tied to sporting outcomes. These products can resemble wagers available through traditional US online sportsbooks , although operators claim different federal regulatory treatment. For companies such as Kalshi and Polymarket, the outcome could determine where they can legally offer sports-related contracts. The senators identified three situations where exchanges should retain geographic restrictions. These include court-ordered restrictions, compliance with tribal gaming requirements and voluntary geofencing. However, their letter does not independently overturn the CFTC's interpretation or existing judicial orders. Consequently, operators could face conflicting obligations while the litigation continues. New People Sworn In to Set the Tone for Oversight The political stakes could also increase in January 2027. Democrats won control of both congressional chambers in the November 3 midterm elections. They will assume their new majorities when the 120th Congress convenes on January 3. This change will give Democrats control of congressional committee leadership and greater oversight authority. In particular, Klobuchar's position could become more influential as her party takes control of the Senate Agriculture Committee. Democratic lawmakers could use hearings, document requests and authorized subpoenas to examine the CFTC's handling of prediction markets. Therefore, the November 16 letter could mark the beginning of broader congressional scrutiny. For now, prediction market operators must navigate an increasingly complicated regulatory environment. The disagreement over geofencing remains unresolved, with further legal and political developments likely to shape the industry's future. This site contains commercial content. We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. Betting News makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event.