Burnham delays end to Palantir’s NHS contract
Andy Burnham has delayed the end of Palantir’s contract with the NHS until 2029. James Frith, the health and social care minister, confirmed that the Government would not sever ties with the US tech giant until five years into its £330m, seven-year deal. Labour MPs and the party’s union backers had demanded that the Government cut ties with Palantir immediately because of its work with the Israeli military and US immigration authorities. But Mr Frith told the Commons: “While future arrangements are developed, and the new procurement process is completed, the current contract will remain for two years, before coming to an end.” The contract contains break clauses, and the Government has decided to trigger the second – to end the contract in March 2029 – rather than the first, in Feb 2027. The Telegraph first revealed in July that Mr Burnham was set to ditch Palantir from the NHS as part of his review of the Government’s overall artificial intelligence strategy. Ministers launched a review of the contract, which formally began in March 2024, earlier this year. Mr Frith said that a tender to eventually replace Palantir was “an opportunity to remake and restate the Government’s commitment to trust in the use of data in such a system”. The current contract makes Palantir the primary software provider for the NHS federated data platform (FDP). The involvement of the firm has led to faster cancer diagnoses, increases in operating theatre use and fewer delays in discharging patients, but has still been vehemently opposed by Labour backbenchers. Review of contract Ministers started a review of the contract, which formally began in March 2024, earlier this year. The seven-year contract contained break clauses, and the Government decided to trigger the second – to end the contract in March 2029 – rather than the first, in February 2027. In July, The Telegraph revealed that Mr Burnham was set to ditch Palantir from the NHS as part of his review of the Government’s overall AI strategy. Allies of the Prime Minister highlighted that the Greater Manchester Combined Authority did not issue a single contract to Palantir under his leadership between 2017 and last month. Addressing the Commons on Monday night, Mr Frith said that the Department of Health and Social Care would soon accept bids from British firms to help replace Palantir. At the same time, it was reported by The Times that Palantir would gear up to launch another bid. The minister confirmed that Yvette Cooper, the Health Secretary, would not trigger a break clause in the deal in Feb 2027 because doing so would lengthen waiting lists. “Trusts and patients are benefiting from those services, and they must remain stable while the future model is designed and procured,” Mr Frith said. “While future arrangements are developed, and the new procurement process is completed, the current contract will remain for two years, before coming to an end.” 110,000 extra operations More than half of NHS trusts in England use Palantir technology. The latest figures from the health service suggest that, since the start of the seven-year contract, the technology has helped to deliver 110,000 extra operations. A memo obtained by The Telegraph in June showed trusts that pioneered the FDP system typically increased theatre utilisation by more than 10 per cent. If it were replicated nationally and the contract ran to its full length, this would have meant around 1.5 million extra operations a year were taking place by 2031. But Mr Frith told the Commons: “A process this important must command public trust as well as clinical confidence. “Public trust is won through clear rules, transparency, independent scrutiny and a demonstrable control over who can access people’s information, for what purpose and under whose authority.” Left-wing critics of Palantir have seized on its work with the Israel Defense Forces and US Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Peter Thiel, the founder and chairman of Palantir, was an early backer of Donald Trump in 2016. Mr Thiel has previously criticised the NHS, saying it needed rebuilding with “market mechanisms”. Alex Karp, Palantir’s chief executive, has also supported Mr Trump. Liz Kendall, the former technology secretary, launched an extraordinary attack on Palantir’s “Right-wing” bosses earlier this year, and refused five times to say whether she believed the firm should have a role in the healthcare system . Mr Burnham’s decision to strip Palantir of its contract is consistent with briefings from his camp throughout his leadership campaign against US tech giants and the Government’s previous AI strategy. Former health chiefs have claimed that campaigning by Left-wing activists was making NHS staff too afraid to voice support for the company’s work for patients. Tom Bartlett, who led the NHS data engineering team that developed the FDP, has said that his former colleagues were “afraid to speak out” for fear of a backlash. The decision to end the contract in 2029 prompted criticism from some Labour backbenchers, who were dissatisfied that it would not end as soon as next spring. Chi Onwurah, the Labour chairman of the Commons science and technology select committee, said: “My committee has repeatedly called on the Government to exercise the 2027 break clause in Palantir’s federated data platform contract with the NHS “It’s deeply disappointing to hear that it won’t do so and is instead choosing to extend the contract for two years, during which time it says it will procure a UK-based supplier.” Ben Coleman, the Labour MP for Chelsea and Fulham, urged ministers to accelerate work on the FDP, claiming that this would help the Government “fully get rid of the albatross of Palantir hanging around the NHS’s neck once and for all”.