Barcelona’s Alejandro Balde plan for January – and what it means for transfer targets
Barcelona were open to selling Alejandro Balde this summer and continue to be so as we approach the January transfer window. Manchester United were one of the clubs who considered a move for the 23-year-old, with the Premier League side looking at a loan deal for a player who, even back then, seemed not to have a place in Hansi Flick’s plans. Almost three months on, Balde has only played 124 minutes across five substitute appearances this term. Not even an injury crisis in defence made the German manager reconsider his approach, and other La Masia prospects have been chosen ahead of him. A La Masia graduate himself, Balde has made 173 Barca appearances since making his first-team debut in 2021 under Ronald Koeman. He has won three La Liga titles, one Copa del Rey and not long ago was seen as one of Europe’s most exciting young left-backs, having also earned seven Spain caps since 2022. Balde is under contract at Barca until 2028, but right now it is difficult to see him having a long-term future at the Camp Nou. Having spoken with several sources close to the situation — who each asked to speak anonymously as they did not have permission to comment — The Athletic explains the latest. Why Barcelona Still Have Financial Issues Amelie Claydon Why are Barcelona open to selling Balde? There are no doubts at Barca that Balde has the physical qualities to perform at the elite level, as well as a decent technical skill set. But the lack of progress in areas he could improve on, such as crossing in the final third, has been frustrating for some of the club’s big decision makers, including Flick. The way Barca are trying to play under the 61-year-old coach also requires a high level of concentration, and it is considered that Balde has struggled to keep up with that over the past two seasons. The improvement Barca had at left-back once Joao Cancelo re-joined on loan in January was clear to the manager last season. As the summer transfer window deadline approached, Balde was left out of a La Liga matchday squad to face Elche on August 23, and Flick told him he was expected to have fewer minutes this season. The situation made Balde consider a departure, but eventually he chose to stay and take on Flick’s challenge to get his starting spot back. Balde has only played 124 minutes for Barcelona this term (Pedro Salado/Getty Images) “Anyone can ask the manager to give them minutes on the pitch to prove themselves, but the place where quality minutes are earned is the training sessions,” a dressing room source at Barcelona told The Athletic last summer when asked about Balde’s situation. Since then, Balde has seen others favoured at the left-back spot ahead of him. Xavi Espart began the new term in that role and the 19-year-old was one of the sensations of Barca’s terrific start to the season. Espart is now injured and might not be available until January, but Cancelo has taken the majority of minutes at left-back and Flick preferred to use another academy graduate, 20-year-old Brian Farinas, to cover injuries at right-back, where even Frenkie de Jong has been deployed before Balde. From a contract point of view, it also makes sense for Barca to consider Balde’s departure. He is going to enter the final year of his deal next summer, and sporting director Deco is not convinced about the idea of offering him a new deal. Selling him later could see their hand weakened in negotiations. What about the player’s view? It was Balde’s choice not to leave this summer. Sources from the player’s camp said he was very comfortable at the club and living in the city in which he was born and raised. Rumours over his future came as soon as the transfer window opened, but Balde was crystal clear about his stance in an interview with Diario Sport in July, during the team’s pre-season training camp at St George’s Park. “Barca is my home,” he said. “I’ve been 16 years at the club, my whole life. I want to succeed and stay many more years.” Those around him, however, admit that he is now more aware of his situation in the squad. That Flick has opted for other players ahead of him made him realise it is not going to be easy to win his place back, but that does not mean he has agreed to any kind of departure. There is also a sense of disappointment on the player’s side over some of the recent interactions between him and Flick. In a press conference last month, the manager said Balde “did not have the confidence he usually needs to play his game, nor the conviction to play as the team wants, pressing high”. The words were read by the full-back as a harsh message, as he had barely had a chance to perform this season. In the following days, Flick had private chats with Balde in which he insisted he was still counting on him, even if he had a smaller role, and wanted him to add competition to the group. “I think Flick does that because he is a good guy and felt bad about how his message to Balde came across,” said a member of Barca’s first-team group. “He felt bad about it and did not want to hurt anybody.” These conflicting messages, however, have not impressed Balde. Does Balde have to leave for the club to sign a centre-back? Barcelona do not have a significant salary margin to register new signings after a busy summer in which they spent around €180million (£150m; $198m) on transfers, including some with significant salaries, such as Rodri. Club sources say departures are required to sanction significant arrivals. It is also worth noting that any fee for Balde, an academy graduate, would be registered as pure profit in Barcelona’s books. There are no fees associated with him that still need to be amortised. But as it stands, no concrete moves have been made for Balde, although Italian newspaper Corriere dello Sport reported on Tuesday that he could be a loan option for Juventus. Manchester United were interested in him in the summer and made a deadline-day check on his situation, but ultimately did not strengthen at left-back in the summer. What’s the latest on Barca’s January targets? The long list of defensive injuries Flick has had to deal with has pushed the club towards making signings in January. Flick said as much in a press conference on October 30. “We are open to signing any player who can make us better,” he said. “There are still a few weeks to go before the winter transfer window, but I have spoken to Deco, (football co-ordinator) Bojan and my assistants. If we can do something, we’ll do it.” Barcelona are exploring options for a left-footed centre-back most of all, but there are no clear leading candidates as of now. Barca sources say they will be monitoring the situation in case a market opportunity arises. Last summer, they looked at Josko Gvardiol, who was in contract talks with Manchester City at the time. The 24-year-old was seen as an ideal candidate to reinforce the defence, but ended up signing a new deal at City. RB Leipzig’s Castello Lukeba was also considered, and local reports have mentioned the name of Manchester United’s Lisandro Martinez as another option. He is nearing the end of his contract at the Old Trafford club, who have just appointed his fellow Argentine Mauricio Pochettino as manager.