After an NHL team canceled Pride Night, fans rallied to give it a new home

DALLAS — On the second floor of the oldest lesbian bar in Texas, Reed Ryan took a break from the party. Ryan was one of several hundred Dallas Stars fans gathered at Sue Ellen’s on Saturday night for the final event of a fan-organized Pride Night that featured vendors, Stars-themed drink specials and a charity raffle. The dance floor was filling up. The karaoke list was getting longer. The night, by any metric, was a success — and the Stars had nothing to do with it. In late August, the team released its promotional schedule, and for the first time since 2019, it did not include an official Pride Night. The decision took the Stars out of step with the NHL at large; last season, 28 of the 32 teams held dedicated Pride Nights, and two held “Hockey is For Everyone” events catered, in part, to LGBTQ+ fans. It also threatened to alienate a section of the fanbase that looked forward to Pride Night as part of its hockey calendar and appreciated a team-supported opportunity to gather at the American Airlines Center, raise money and enjoy themselves in a visible way. “The thing that we loved the most about the Pride nights in the past,” Tori Copeland, co-organizer of Saturday’s event along with Ryan, said, “was getting to just hang out with everyone ... (I)t’s really, really fun to have one night a year where everyone is at the game, and you get to see everyone and have such a positive experience.” The Stars, who are trying to secure funding for a new arena in suburban Plano, took that off the table. For Ryan and Copeland, the work to create a viable replacement began immediately — and a little more than two months later, they’d built something of their own. That, Ryan said from a corner of the karaoke room, was the point. Dallas Stars' fans host alternate Pride night after team cancels Sean Gentille “I love this hockey team,” Ryan said. “As much as they anger me, they’re such a vital and important part of my life. We could have easily just boycotted them, but that wouldn’t have sat well with me. Still, we’ve got to show them that we’re here and we deserve to be celebrated and that we are not going to go down quietly. “I think that’s the best way that we could do that: Show them that you may not do it for us, but we’re going to do it ourselves.” Over the summer, Copeland said, there’d been online rumblings among Stars fans that Pride Night was in trouble. Backlash to the 2025 version had seemed more intense, though the event itself had been downsized a bit, and the team was taking longer to release the promotional schedule than it had in years past. When the news hit on Aug. 28, Copeland was disappointed, but not surprised. In place of Pride was an event celebrating women in sports and a plan to “use our platform to celebrate and support a different underrepresented community each season,” Stars spokesperson Joe Calvillo said in a statement released to media outlets at the time. The afternoon of the announcement, Copeland, a stylist with a strong social media following, tweeted that she’d be hosting her own Pride Night, and that everyone was invited. The response from her followers was immediate. “My first thought was, ‘I have the platform to do this. If it’s five people or 500 people, I don’t care, I’ll set up something for everyone,’” she said. Ryan messaged Copeland — the two were already friends — saying that he was in, too, and suggested incorporating a fundraiser for Dallas Hope Charities, a 501(c)(3) group that, in part, provides housing for LGBTQ+ youth. The group been foregrounded at past Pride Nights and, it stood to reason, would miss out on donations because of the cancellation. “I wanted it to be a local charity that meant a lot to a lot of us,” Ryan said. Even as Ryan and Copeland spitballed plans for a raffle and an after-party at Sue Ellen’s, they figured the scope would stay relatively small. Nothing with the bar, for example, was made official; the plan was to drop by after the game. “It was ‘let’s see what happens,’” Ryan said. “I really thought it would just be our little friend group.” The plan picked up enough momentum to catch the attention of event planner Elle Lurry, who saw an online flyer that mentioned Sue Ellen’s as the after-party spot, then called the bar and offered to help. “They were like, ‘What after-party?’” Lurry said. Lurry “sleuthed online,” figured out Copeland was the initial point person and got involved. By September, she’d officially brought the bar on board, secured artists and merch vendors and designed a Stars-themed drink menu featuring items like Oetter’s Water (vodka, soda, lemonade) and Puck Off, a non-alcoholic option named after the Stars’ Pantera-written goal song. Also added to the schedule: a pregame gathering at Happiest Hour, a gigantic indoor/outdoor bar a few blocks down Nowitzki Way from the arena. On Saturday, the Pride group took over a handful of picnic tables for poster designing, bracelet giveaways and early raffle entries. “(Lurry has) been out of this world,” Ryan said. “I don’t think any of this would have happened here if it wasn’t for her setting it up.” (Courtesy of Rae Walts) Fans who’d stopped by the pregame event weren’t tough to spot in the arena; many had picked up Pride flags and designed rainbow-bordered posters. Natalie Machala, who’d attended every official Pride Night in Dallas and was at Saturday night’s game with her wife and friends, made a poster in anticipation of Stars captain Jamie Benn picking up his 1,000th career point. (Benn did, scoring the only goal of the game in a 1-0 win over the Buffalo Sabres.) “The people that organized this did a better job than the Stars organization has ever done,” Machala said. “I would look forward to that again, and I would hope that the Stars organization would be a part of it and support it.” For Copeland, Ryan and the rest of their group, that’s the ideal outcome. It’s also part of the reason they didn’t call for a boycott. “Our ultimate goal is maybe to get the Stars to one day bring it back,” Copeland said. “And I feel like if we get on social media and start yelling, ‘F— the Stars,’ they may take it and be like, ‘Actually, well, f— you guys, too. We’re not ever doing this again.'” Asked over the weekend to comment on the fan-driven event, the Stars declined and said: “Our only comment is the statement that we sent back in August.” The NHL also was given a chance to comment on the Stars’ decision to cancel Pride Night, and the fans’ organization of their own event, and a spokesperson said: “We think it’s great when fans find ways to connect with our game.” The party eventually moved to Sue Ellen’s after starting at Happiest Hour. (Sean Gentille / The Athletic) Ideally, the organizers said, top decision-makers in the Stars organization would treat the LGBTQ+ community as a valuable part of the fanbase. “We’re spending $50 on a print, $60 on a Stars hat,” Lurry said. “We have money to spend. We want to keep spending it on the Stars. So do better.” There was also a desire to ensure that people within the organization who do support them don’t feel awkward — a group, Copeland says, that far outweighs the alternative — and that LGBTQ+ Stars fans don’t feel pressured into making unnecessarily tough decisions. “Not hosting (Pride) one year doesn’t dismantle the community that already existed,” said Rae Walts, who volunteered as the evening’s official photographer. “You’ve seen a lot of change in the demographics of people who are invested in this sport as a whole. And I think they’re still trying to figure out exactly what to do with that. And they could have handled it better. As a whole, the NHL, individual teams, whatever — I think they are trying to figure it out. But them trying to figure it out has no impact on the people who are here that love the sport, even if the sport doesn’t always love you back.” Copeland compared the approach to “gentle parenting.” “And now we’ve made it bigger than anything they would have ever thrown, anyway,” she said. “Y’all could’ve just held it and it wouldn’t have been a big deal. ... Hopefully that teaches them a lesson.” If not, Ryan said, so it goes. He said Carolina Hurricanes fans have already reached out for pointers on throwing their own similar event, and that the raffle raised approximately $3,500 for Dallas Hope Charities. The vibes at Sue Ellen’s couldn’t have gotten much better. “I hope good things come from it,” he said. “If it’s not the team seeing the demand for (Pride), then at least other fandoms seeing that they can do what we’re doing and they can make a difference in their community.” A few moments later, as Ryan left the karaoke room and walked back toward the vendors, “Puck Off” blared.